FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT101E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-1: What Is Biblical Theology?

One Bible, three different questions

Introduction to Biblical Theology

15 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Geerhardus Vos's definition of biblical theology and explain what makes it a genuinely different discipline from systematic theology, not merely a more historical version of it.
  • Summarize Charles Hodge's systematic method and explain what a topical, cross-canon arrangement of doctrine is well suited to do.
  • Describe Brevard Childs's canonical approach as a third option distinct from both, and say what question it is trying to answer that neither Vos nor Hodge is asking.
  • Explain why topical proof-texting is not the same thing as systematic theology, and why the failure mode this course warns against most often is the informal one, not the academic one.
  • Identify at least one task each of the three approaches performs that the other two do not.
The puzzle

One verse, three readers

Ask three trained readers what 2 Timothy 3:16 is doing in the Bible, and you may hear three answers. A systematic theologian files it under the doctrine of inspiration, beside 2 Peter 1:20-21. A topical preacher uses it to prove the Bible's authority and moves on. A biblical theologian first asks what Paul was doing in this letter, to this young pastor, at this moment. The verse never changes; what changes is whether it is read as a freestanding claim or as one move in Paul's argument.

Key idea Neither approach is "the wrong one". They ask different questions of the same text.
Scripture

Why 2 Timothy 3:16?

This verse is the lecture's test case. Paul wrote it to Timothy, who had to survive false teaching in Ephesus, and he reminded him that the writings he had known "from infancy" were God-breathed. Read alone, it sounds like a general statement about the Bible. Read in its letter, it is one step in an argument. Seeing that difference is the whole point of the lecture.

Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness, 2 Timothy 3:16 · World English Bible
Geerhardus Vos

The founding claim

Vos held the first chair of biblical theology at Princeton Theological Seminary from 1893. His book opens with a definition: biblical theology is "that branch of Exegetical Theology which deals with the process of the self-revelation of God deposited in the Bible." Later writers often shorten this sentence and lose its force. The discipline is exegesis practiced with a historical eye: it reads each text first as a moment in an unfolding history of God disclosing himself.

Key idea Read each text as one moment in a history, before filing it under a topic.
Two key words

"Process" and "deposited"

The first word, process, means Vos is not studying different contents than systematic theology. He studies the same Bible as an unfolding sequence, not as a finished deposit to be sorted by subject. The second word, deposited, means this process is revelation: God disclosing himself, with Scripture as the trustworthy record. Vos claims that the very shape of revelation, in installments over about fifteen centuries, is itself theologically significant. It is not just a delivery method for timeless statements that could have arrived all at once.

Key idea There is real theological work in tracing the process itself.
Charles Hodge

The systematic task

Hodge, Vos's older colleague, organized all of Christian doctrine by topic in his three-volume Systematic Theology. A chapter on justification can move from Genesis 15:6 to Romans 4 to Galatians 3 in one page. His method is to gather "the facts of Scripture" on a subject and to draw out the general truths they imply. This is careful comparison across the whole canon, not careless verse-stringing, and it answers a question biblical theology alone cannot: what does the whole Bible teach about a doctrine, stated so that a church can confess it together?

Key idea A creed in church relies on centuries of exactly this kind of work.
Brevard Childs

A third question

Childs, working mainly at Yale, asked how a text functions as canon: in its final, received form, read as Scripture by a community of faith. He did not ignore the history Vos traces, but he insisted that the church reads Genesis as the book that stands in the canon, not mainly as a reconstructed pre-history or raw material for doctrine. A canonical reading of Isaiah asks how chapters 1-39 and 40-66 work together as one book. This course follows Vos far more often, but you should know this serious third option exists.

Key idea "Process" and "topic" are not the only two ways to read.
Be careful

Casual proof-texting

The failure this course worries about most is not academic systematic theology. It sits in ordinary practice: a reader or preacher who treats verses as interchangeable, freestanding facts. Casual proof-texting borrows the outer form of Hodge's method, a verse cited to settle a topic, without the discipline that makes his method responsible. That discipline is patient comparison of each text's own argument, in its own setting, against every other relevant text.

Key idea The warning is aimed at the casual habit, not at scholars.
Scripture

Why John 5:39?

Jesus says this to religious leaders who searched the Scriptures with great care and still missed him. That shows that careful reading alone, apart from reading rightly, is not enough. It also keeps this lecture honest: the verse that says Scripture testifies about Jesus is not permission to skip context. It is a warning to read the whole text in light of where it is going.

You search the Scriptures, because you think that in them you have eternal life; and these are they which testify about me. John 5:39 · WEB
At a glance

Three approaches, one Bible

Vos · biblical theology

Reads along the unfolding timeline. This is the method of this course. It shows why a promise to Abraham in Genesis 12 still controls Paul's argument in Galatians 3.

Hodge · systematic theology

Reads across the whole canon by topic. It states what a church confesses, for example on the Lord's Supper or the Trinity.

Childs · canonical approach

Reads the finished, received form. It asks how a book functions as Scripture for a worshiping community. It is a third question, not a referee.

Putting it together

What each discipline is for

None of the three replaces the others, and this course does not ask you to choose one and discard the rest. Biblical theology is poor, on its own, at answering whether the Lord's Supper is a sacrament or an ordinance, because that needs topical comparison. Systematic theology, if practiced without biblical theology, can flatten the very sequence by which God revealed things. The chapters that follow lean almost entirely on Vos's method. That is a decision about which discipline this course teaches, not a verdict that the others are inferior.

Key idea Same Bible. Different question. None replaces the others.
Think about it

Proof-texting in practice

Most of us have heard a doctrine defended mainly by citation. A list of verses is read one after another, with little comment on where each verse sits in its own book. Think of a real case you remember before you answer.

Was that closer to Hodge's disciplined systematic method or to casual proof-texting? What would need to change to tell the difference in practice?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Vos defined biblical theology as tracing "the process of the self-revelation of God deposited in the Bible", reading each text as a moment in an unfolding history. Hodge's systematic theology asks a different, equally legitimate question: what does the whole Bible teach on a doctrine? Childs's canonical approach asks how a book functions in its finished form for the church. None replaces the others. The danger this course targets is casual proof-texting, which John 5:39 shows can coexist with diligent searching that still misses Christ.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 15