Lecture 2-1: Scripture as a Story with a Plot
Is the Bible a manual to look things up in, or one story with a plot?
Introduction to Biblical Theology
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Is the Bible a manual to look things up in, or one story with a plot?
Introduction to Biblical Theology
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Open a Bible at random and you might land in a genealogy, a law code, a battle report, a love poem or a letter about circumcision. It is tempting to think this variety means the Bible is a shelf of unrelated books with one cover. Chapter 1 already rejected one version of this temptation, reading Scripture only by topic. This lecture names a second one: reading Scripture only as a manual of information to look up, with no larger shape joining one lookup to the next.
The lecture argues that Scripture, across all its genres, authors and languages, tells a single continuous story. It has the features of a narrative: an opening situation, a disruption of that situation, a long and complicated struggle to resolve it, a climax, and a resolution that is still opening out toward an ending not yet reached. This does not erase the real differences between a psalm and a law code. It places each of them inside a larger movement that both serve.
A manual is organized for retrieval. Its ideal reader opens it to one page, gets an answer to one question and closes it again. The order of its parts hardly matters, because each part stands alone. The lecture says a great deal of value can be taken from Scripture this way: a verse of comfort in grief, a command made clear, a definition looked up. Concordances, topical study Bibles and doctrinal proof-texting all depend on this use. Nothing in the lecture calls that kind of reading illegitimate.
The difficulty is that a manual cannot explain itself as movement. Its parts are simultaneous, not sequential; no chapter in it depends on having read an earlier one. But Genesis 12's promise to Abraham is not simultaneous with Galatians 3's argument about that promise. Galatians depends on Genesis, refers back to it, and would be a different and weaker argument without it. A manual cannot represent this kind of dependency, because dependency across time is exactly what narrative, not reference material, is built to carry.
This is the story's opening line in the most literal sense: it is the first verse. The lecture says every narrative needs an initial situation before a plot can move, and that this verse is about as minimal and complete an exposition as a story can have. It says there is a God, distinct from what he makes, and an ordered creation that begins as a plain assertion, not an argument to be proven. The lecture uses the verse for this one purpose, to mark where the plot starts.
In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth. Genesis 1:1
The lecture says any competent story, biblical or not, tends to show the same structural elements. An exposition sets up the starting situation and its characters. A conflict disrupts that situation. In the rising action the conflict grows, and attempts to resolve it fail or only partly succeed. The climax is the decisive turning point. The resolution settles the conflict, although a resolution can itself stay open, pointing to consequences still working themselves out.
Genesis 1-2: a good creation, with humanity given a task within it.
Genesis 3: rebellion against the creator, and its immediate and spreading consequences.
Patriarchs, exodus, monarchy, exile and the prophets' unresolved hope. Partial resolutions such as a judge, a good king or a return from exile keep failing to be the resolution the story needs.
The death and resurrection of Jesus.
The church age, moving toward a still-future new creation. It is settled in one sense, because the decisive victory has happened, and still unfolding in another. Chapter 3 returns to this.
N. T. Wright, in The New Testament and the People of God, offers one influential way to hold this shape together: think of Scripture as an unfinished five-act play. Act One is creation. Act Two is the fall. Act Three is Israel, called and bound by covenant as God's way of answering the fall. Act Four is Jesus, whose life, death and resurrection are the play's decisive turn. Act Five is the church, living out the meaning of Act Four while the final scene has not yet been played.
The word unfinished matters. Actors in an unfinished play cannot just recite a final act that is already written, because no one has that script. Instead, actors trained in the earlier acts must improvise the next scene faithfully, consistent with the characters, conflicts and direction already set. Wright's point is that the church's task is like this: not inventing a new story, and not replaying Act Three or Four word for word. The lecture adds that the image is suggestive, not exact, and can be pressed too far.
Craig Bartholomew and Michael Goheen, in The Drama of Scripture, give a closely related account with six acts: creation, fall, Israel, Christ, church and consummation. Like Wright, they insist that Scripture's parts are scenes in one drama, not entries in an encyclopedia. Their special concern is pastoral. A community that loses the story's shape starts mining Scripture for isolated moral sayings, or unconsciously lets another story, such as consumerism, nationalism or self-fulfillment, organize daily life.
Paul is discussing Israel's wilderness generation: the golden calf, the grumbling and the plagues that followed. The lecture notes that he says these events "happened" and "were written" with later readers in view, readers at what he calls "the ends of the ages." The lecture reads this as assuming that the story has an identifiable direction and that the Corinthian church stands somewhere significant in it. It says such a verse is hard to explain if the Old Testament is only background information.
Now all these things happened to them by way of example, and they were written for our admonition, on whom the ends of the ages have come. 1 Corinthians 10:11
The lecture says plainly that reading Scripture as one story is itself an interpretive decision. Historical criticism since the Enlightenment reads the biblical documents mainly as separate ancient sources and would resist the claim of one intended plot. This course takes a position in that older disagreement: it reads the canon as a coherent whole under divine oversight, without denying the real human authors and settings. The lecture calls this a confessional starting point held across the church's traditions, not something source criticism alone could show.
Many of us have a verse we mainly use as a manual entry: a verse for comfort, or a rule to follow. The lecture does not say this use is wrong. It asks what changes when the same verse is placed in the larger story.
Choose one such passage. What changes about how you read it when you ask where it sits in the story, from exposition to a resolution still opening?
Scripture works as a narrative, not only a manual. Its parts depend on each other across time, as Galatians 3 depends on Genesis 12. The story runs from exposition in Genesis 1-2 and conflict in Genesis 3, through a long rising action, to its climax at the cross and resurrection and a resolution still opening in the church age. Wright's five acts and Bartholomew and Goheen's six make the same point. Lose the story's shape, and you may flatten Scripture into moral sayings or live inside a different story. The lecture also says that reading Scripture as one story is a confessional starting point.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.