FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT401E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-2: Canon Formation and the Scope Debate

Careful readers of the same evidence draw the boundary differently

Introduction to the Old Testament

11 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the difference in scope between Protestant, Catholic, and Orthodox Old Testaments, and name at least three specific deuterocanonical/apocryphal books.
  • Explain what is meant by "canon formation" and why it is a historical process rather than a single decision made at one meeting.
  • Present Roger Beckwith's case for an early-closed Hebrew canon in its own terms.
  • Present the case for a wider, Septuagint-based canon, including why Albert Sundberg's name is associated with questioning an early "Alexandrian canon."
  • Explain why this course treats the scope question as genuinely open rather than resolved.
The difference

Three Old Testaments, three lists

A Protestant Old Testament has thirty-nine books. A Catholic one has forty-six, adding Tobit, Judith, 1-2 Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, and additions to Esther and Daniel. Orthodox Bibles are wider still, typically including 1 Esdras, 3 Maccabees and Psalm 151. The lecture says this means Christians reading "the Old Testament" are not all reading the same book.

Key idea The disagreement is about a specific set of books, not about Genesis through Malachi.
At a glance

Three names for the disputed books

Catholic: deuterocanonical

The term means "belonging to a second canon." Following the Council of Trent (1546), which formalized an older usage, Catholic tradition affirms these books as fully canonical.

Protestant: Apocrypha

The Reformers appealed to the Hebrew canon used by Jews of their day. They printed these books alongside the canonical ones, as worth reading but not scripture in the same sense.

Orthodox: the widest list

Orthodox tradition is less centralized in setting its canon and has historically been widest, with some variation between Greek, Slavic and other communions.

Process

Why these books are in question

The disputed books were written mostly in the last few centuries before Christ, and several were written originally in Greek. They circulated widely among Greek-speaking Jews and appear in the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew scriptures. By the time rabbinic Judaism settled its own canon, they were generally excluded from the Hebrew Bible. The lecture treats canon formation as a historical process, not one decision at one meeting.

Key idea The question is about books on the edge of the Hebrew canon.
Case one

Beckwith: an early-closed canon

Roger Beckwith argues the Hebrew canon was substantially fixed well before Jesus, closed in practice by the early second century BC at the latest. He points to the Sirach prologue (around 132 BC), which refers to "the law, the prophets, and the other books." He also cites Josephus, who counts twenty-two books and says no one has dared to add to them or take from them. On his reading, the deuterocanonical books were known and sometimes quoted but never counted in the closed collection.

Key idea Beckwith reads a settled Jewish consensus, not a late reaction to Christianity.
Case two

Sundberg: a fluid boundary

Albert Sundberg's 1964 book pressed the alternative case. The Septuagint, which most diaspora Jews used and New Testament writers quoted, regularly circulated with the deuterocanonical books alongside the others. Sundberg argued that a fixed "Alexandrian canon" was a modern scholarly construction without solid ancient evidence. He held that scripture's boundary was still fluid well into the Christian era, with different communities using different, overlapping lists.

Key idea On this view the early church received a wider body of writings.
Honest disagreement

The course does not pick a winner

The lecture calls both cases serious and textually grounded. It notes that many Catholic and Orthodox readers hold the wider canon with good historical reason, while many Protestants hold the narrower one. This course does not resolve the question, and no quiz asks you to treat the other answer as simply a mistake. The lecture adds that Revelation 22:18, a warning against adding to a book, is a poor proof-text for settling the question, even though it is sometimes cited that way.

Key idea Each tradition's list has a history behind it.
Think about it

Explaining your own list

The lecture says that assuming your own tradition's list is simply "the Bible", with no history behind the boundary, leaves a student unable to understand other faithful Christians.

Does knowing this history change how you would explain your own tradition's Old Testament to a Christian from a different tradition? Why or why not?

Recap

What to carry forward

Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Old Testaments differ in scope: thirty-nine books, forty-six, or more. Beckwith argues for an early-closed Hebrew canon, using the Sirach prologue and Josephus. Sundberg argues that no single fixed Alexandrian canon existed and that the boundary was fluid. The stakes reach beyond counting: 1-2 Maccabees gives background for chapter 32, and 2 Maccabees 12 has been cited in debates about prayer for the dead.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11