Lecture 2-1: The Ancient Near East and How to Use It Responsibly
Comparison is unavoidable, so use it responsibly
Introduction to the Old Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Comparison is unavoidable, so use it responsibly
Introduction to the Old Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
The Old Testament's first readers lived among peoples who also told how the world began, wrote down laws, built temples and offered sacrifices. The lecture says a reader who skips the Ancient Near East is not reading the text "purely." That reader is using a twenty-first-century imagination in place of the ancient one the text assumes. Both default pictures, the modern one and the vaguely biblical-movie one, are wrong.
A Babylonian creation epic. Marduk defeats the chaos-goddess Tiamat and humanity is made from a defeated rebel god's blood. It was recited at Babylon's New Year festival as state religion.
A Mesopotamian epic about a king of Uruk. Its eleventh tablet has a flood story in which Utnapishtim survives in a boat and is granted immortality.
A Babylonian law collection from the eighteenth century BC with close to three hundred case laws. Some resemble Exodus 21-23, such as the case of an ox that gores a person.
The lecture uses this passage because it holds up Israel's law against "the peoples" as something a watching world will recognize as wise. The lecture says the text itself invites comparison and does not expect to lose it.
Keep therefore and do them; for this is your wisdom and your understanding in the sight of the peoples, who shall hear all these statutes, and say, "Surely this great nation is a wise and understanding people." For what great nation is there, that has a god so near to them, as Yahweh our God is whenever we call on him? What great nation is there, that has statutes and ordinances so righteous as all this law, which I set before you this day? WEB, Deuteronomy 4:6-8
The first mistake treats the Old Testament as derivative, as if Genesis were Israel's version of a story borrowed from Babylon. That reading treats "shares a shape with" and "borrowed from, with nothing of its own to say" as the same claim. The second mistake treats every difference as the whole theological point and every similarity as an embarrassment. The lecture says this reading is just as selective, because it chooses which data counts based on the conclusion it already wants.
John Walton argues that ancient Near Eastern peoples, Israel included, cared more about functional origins than material ones. The question was not where the raw stuff came from but how a place became ordered and working. Read that way, Genesis 1's seven days may describe a cosmic temple being inaugurated for its divine occupant. The lecture says comparative material tells you what questions the original audience was and was not asking.
Kenneth Kitchen is an Egyptologist who argues that comparative evidence is often used selectively. It is invoked when it seems to undercut the Old Testament's claims and set aside when it would support them. He points to second-millennium BC treaty forms and legal conventions that he says fit the patriarchal narratives and the Sinai covenant. The lecture presents his caution as methodological: evidence is not admitted only when it points one way.
First, similarity of shape is not evidence of shared meaning. The Genesis flood and the Gilgamesh flood share an outline, but Genesis 6:11 frames the flood as judgment on violence, while Gilgamesh frames it as divine irritation at human noise. Second, comparative material is background, not a verdict. It cannot by itself settle whether the Old Testament is true or authoritative. Third, claims that Israel definitely borrowed from Babylon, or the reverse, usually go beyond the evidence.
The lecture says the flood narratives share a recognizable outline but not a theology.
Can you think of another case where two texts share a structure yet say different things? What would it take to show that one depends on the other?
The Enuma Elish, Gilgamesh and the Code of Hammurabi share real shapes with Old Testament passages without sharing their theology. Walton reads Genesis 1 as answering a functional question, and Kitchen insists comparative evidence be used consistently. The lecture's working rule is that similarity of shape is not shared meaning. Comparative material informs a reading but cannot, by itself, hand down a verdict on the text's truth.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.