FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT401E · Chapter 9

Lecture 9-1: The Deuteronomistic History Hypothesis

Noth proposed one history running from Joshua to Kings

Introduction to the Old Testament

12 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Martin Noth's Deuteronomistic History hypothesis in your own words, including which books it covers and what evidence Noth pointed to.
  • Identify the recurring literary and theological markers Noth used to argue for one continuous editorial hand (regnal formulas, retrospective speeches, the evaluation vocabulary).
  • Explain how the hypothesis has since been revised (the "double redaction" proposals of the exilic and pre-exilic editions) without needing to adjudicate between the revisions.
  • Describe how evangelical scholarship has engaged Noth's proposal — which part of it a scholar can accept and which part a scholar can resist, and why those are separable questions.
  • Connect Deuteronomy's treaty theology (chapter 8) to the evaluation formula that recurs from Judges through Kings.
The proposal

What Noth actually proposed

Before Martin Noth, the standard critical view treated Joshua as part of a "Hexateuch," Genesis through Joshua, traced to the same sources as the Pentateuch. Judges, Samuel and Kings were seen as a looser collection. Noth's 1943 work broke that picture from both directions. Joshua does not belong with the Pentateuch's sources. Judges, Samuel and Kings are the deliberate continuation of a single work that begins in Deuteronomy.

Key idea Noth's case rested on three kinds of evidence, each checkable against the text.
Three kinds of evidence

How Noth built the case

A shared vocabulary

From Judges to Kings the narrator judges kings and generations in language that echoes Deuteronomy: "did what was evil in the sight of Yahweh," "walked in the way of David his father."

Speeches at the joints

Major retrospective speeches fall at the seams between eras: Joshua 23-24, 1 Samuel 12, 1 Kings 8 and 2 Kings 17. Each looks back at what has happened and forward to what the covenant requires.

One explanatory purpose

The whole work explains why the exile happened.

Purpose

An argument addressed to a displaced people

Noth dated the work to the exile, composed by one editor in Babylon not long after 561 BC, the date 2 Kings 25:27 gives for Jehoiachin's release. The editor used older sources and shaped them toward one goal. On this reading the history is not only a record of events. It argues to a defeated people that the exile was no accident and no victory of stronger gods, but the fulfillment of the covenant curses of Deuteronomy 28.

Key idea The history is an argument as well as a record.
Terms

Deuteronomistic, not simply Deuteronomic

"Deuteronomic" describes Deuteronomy itself. "Deuteronomistic" describes a style and theology that imitates Deuteronomy's, the work of an editor or school writing in its idiom. Noth claimed that this second voice runs continuously from Joshua 1:7-8, which frames the conquest as obedience to the law Moses commanded, to the end of 2 Kings.

Key idea The label separates Deuteronomy's own author from an imitating editor.
Revisions

One edition or two?

Noth saw one exilic editor with no expectation of restoration. Two difficulties pushed later scholars to revise this. Some material is hopeful about the Davidic monarchy, such as the promise of 2 Samuel 7, beside condemnation of kings after Solomon. And the account of Josiah's reform in 2 Kings 22-23 reads as if written for a monarchy still standing and still hopeful.

Key idea The difficulties are in the text itself.
Two revisions

Cross and Smend

Frank Moore Cross

A double redaction: a first edition under Josiah in the late seventh century BC, supporting his reforms and hope for David's line, and a second exilic edition that added the material about the fall.

Rudolf Smend and the Gottingen school

A series of exilic and post-exilic layers distinguished by emphasis, such as prophecy or strict law-observance, rather than one pre-exilic and exilic split.

Evangelical engagement

What to keep, what to resist

Noth's core observation is that Joshua through Kings reads as one connected story, judged throughout by Deuteronomy's covenant categories. Many evangelical scholars accept it in that limited form. Many resist the bundled assumption that this coherence proves late invention, or that theological shaping counts against historical reliability. A history can be both shaped by a clear argument and substantially accurate.

Key idea The observation and the compositional theory built on it are two different claims.
Think about it

Accepting a description, not a conclusion

The lecture says this move recurs constantly in Old Testament scholarship: accepting a scholar's description of a text's shape while resisting the historical conclusions built on it.

Where have you seen someone accept an observation but reject the conclusion drawn from it?

Recap

What to carry forward

Noth argued that Joshua through Kings is one history in Deuteronomy's voice, built on a shared vocabulary, speeches at the joints and a single purpose of explaining the exile. Later scholars revised the one-editor picture, with Cross proposing two editions and Smend's school proposing several layers. Even those who accept the literary observation disagree about how many editors worked and when. The observation and the theory are separate claims.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12