Lecture 10-2: Models of Israelite Origins in the Land
Three models explain the conquest, and none has won
Introduction to the Old Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Three models explain the conquest, and none has won
Introduction to the Old Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Judges 1 lists Canaanite towns Israel did not drive out, including Jerusalem, Gezer and Beth-shean, some still resisting "to this day." Joshua 11:23 says Joshua took the whole land. This is a tension inside the canon, not a modern invention. Excavations at Jericho and Ai also give results that archaeologists dispute. Three different reconstructions have been proposed, and each has serious defenders today.
The lecture reads this as the conquest narrative's own summary statement, specifically for what it claims about completeness.
So Joshua took the whole land, according to all that Yahweh spoke to Moses; and Joshua gave it for an inheritance to Israel according to their divisions by their tribes. The land had rest from war. World English Bible
A real and relatively rapid military conquest by an invading Israelite group.
Seminomadic herders gradually and largely peacefully settled the highlands.
Israel was largely indigenous Canaanite peasants and marginalized groups who rose against the city-state system.
Albright and Wright argued that Joshua describes, in broad outline, a real and fairly rapid conquest. Albright pointed to destruction layers at several sites as best explained by an Israelite conquest. The model takes Joshua's account most nearly at face value. Its weakness is that some destruction layers have since been redated, and the record at Jericho and Ai does not obviously support what Joshua 6 and 8 describe.
Alt and Noth proposed that Israel was never a unified army. Seminomadic groups gradually settled the sparsely populated highlands, and later sometimes clashed with Canaanites. On this model, Joshua's single campaign is a later theological telescoping of a long process. It explains Judges 1's messier picture well. Its weakness is explaining Joshua's detailed destruction stories at named sites like Jericho and Hazor.
Mendenhall and Gottwald proposed that Israel was substantially made up of indigenous peasants who rose against oppressive city-state rule. A small group with a distinct Yahwistic identity, plausibly linked to the exodus tradition, supplied the ideology. On this model, the conquest is largely an internal social revolution retold as an invasion. Direct evidence for the mechanism is thin, and critics say it reads a modern category, class revolution, back into the text.
Kenneth Kitchen does not offer a fourth model. He argues from within a conquest-sympathetic position that critical reconstructions have outrun the evidence. He points to Near Eastern comparative material on destruction, settlement and population movement, and says a historical Israelite emergence with real military engagement remains a defensible reading, even where Jericho and Ai stay uncertain. The lecture says this is a caution, not a claim that every detail of Joshua 6-12 can be verified.
The lecture cites the Gibeonite treaty as evidence internal to Joshua that its account is not simple everywhere: at least one Canaanite population was absorbed by covenant, not destroyed.
But when the inhabitants of Gibeon heard what Joshua had done to Jericho and to Ai, they also resorted to a ruse, and went and made as if they had been ambassadors... Joshua made peace with them, and made a covenant with them, to let them live. The princes of the congregation swore to them. WEB
Joshua 11:23 and Judges 1 seem to pull in different directions, and archaeology at Jericho and Ai is disputed. Three models respond: conquest, peaceful infiltration and peasant revolt. Each pays a real cost somewhere in the text or the evidence, and none is the scholarly consensus. Joshua itself includes absorption stories, such as Rahab and the Gibeonites. The lecture does not treat any one model as consensus or dismiss the others as apologetics.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.