Lecture 10-3: The Ethical Problem of Herem
The herem command is a real difficulty, held honestly
Introduction to the Old Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
The herem command is a real difficulty, held honestly
Introduction to the Old Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Herem, sometimes translated "the ban," is not just ancient warfare's ordinary brutality. It is commanded, attributed to Yahweh's own instruction (Deuteronomy 7:2; 20:17), and applied categorically to whole peoples. "You shall save alive nothing that breathes" (Deuteronomy 20:16). On the plain sense of Joshua 6:21 this included children. The lecture says a reader who treats it as background noise has not read closely, since herem sits inside the chapters that make the covenant-fulfillment argument.
The lecture reads this passage as the command form of herem, given in advance of Israel's entry into the land.
When Yahweh your God brings you into the land where you go to possess it, and casts out many nations before you, the Hittite, the Girgashite, the Amorite, the Canaanite, the Perizzite, the Hivite, and the Jebusite, seven nations greater and mightier than you; and when Yahweh your God delivers them up before you, and you strike them; then you shall utterly destroy them. You shall make no covenant with them, nor show mercy to them. World English Bible
In Deuteronomy and Joshua, herem is applied to named peoples within the promised land, not as a general policy toward all nations. Deuteronomy 20:10-15 treats cities far off differently. Deuteronomy 20:18 gives a rationale: preventing Israel from adopting these nations' religious practices. And Joshua's narrative includes the Gibeonites, spared by treaty, and Rahab, spared by mercy. None of this changes what Joshua 6:21 says or removes the difficulty.
The lecture says readers come with real and sometimes painful histories. Colonial violence has been justified in living memory by appeal to Joshua's conquest narrative as a template. That history is a reason for extra care in how the material is taught, not a reason to avoid teaching it. A teacher who has never sat with a genuine question about how a good God could command this has probably not had enough honest conversations about the Old Testament.
Some scholars working from comparative Ancient Near Eastern military texts argue that "utterly destroy" language was stock hyperbole in conquest accounts, like the boasts on royal victory monuments. On this reading, Judges 1's surviving Canaanites confirm that Joshua was never meant to be read literally. The lecture says this has real comparative support, but it relocates the difficulty more than it removes it: Deuteronomy 20:16 is harder to read as pure convention, and Joshua 6:21 gives a specific description.
A second reading follows the text's own rationale: herem is divine judgment on genuinely wicked societies, anticipated in the Amorite language of Genesis 15:16. Israel is the instrument of a judgment Yahweh delayed for centuries, and Deuteronomy 9:4-5 says Israel's righteousness is not the basis. The cost, as the lecture puts it, is that it does not explain why a judgment on a society's wickedness would extend to children, which raises the wider question of corporate and individual guilt across the Old Testament.
Paul Copan combines the hyperbole reading with an emphasis on herem's strict limits: a specific population, a specific land and a specific moment tied to the patriarchal covenant. Scripture never presents it as a standing policy toward outsiders. This blocks its use as a template, which matters given the history of colonial appeals. Critics reply that a command's limited scope does not by itself answer whether it was right to give even once.
Christopher J.H. Wright, without abandoning the text's authority, reads herem as one voice within a Scripture that contains tension and development on violence and enemy-love, visible when the whole canon is read together and reaching Jesus' teaching on loving enemies. The interpreter's task is not to fully harmonize Joshua 6 with Matthew 5, but to let both stand as Scripture. The lecture notes that this asks more of the reader than a tidy solution would.
Herem is a commanded, categorical act applied to named peoples, and the text itself includes limits and exceptions. Four responses are surveyed: hyperbolic rhetoric, corporate judgment, a limited non-repeatable command, and a text held in tension. The lecture names none as correct. It insists a reader neither pretend the difficulty away by editing what the text says, nor treat it as a reason to set the text aside. Serious readers who honor the text's authority differ here.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.