FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT401E · Chapter 22

Lecture 22-2: The Interpretive Debate — Allegory and the Literal Reading

Allegory and the literal reading are two long-standing ways to read the Song

Introduction to the Old Testament

12 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the allegorical reading's central claim and identify at least two major representatives across its long history.
  • State the literal reading's central claim and identify at least two of its contemporary scholarly representatives.
  • Explain the strongest textual and historical arguments each side offers for its position.
  • Explain the strongest objections each side raises against the other.
  • Articulate why this debate is not merely academic — what is actually at stake for how a reader uses the Song.
The debate

Two readings, both carefully defended

No Old Testament book has been read in two more different ways than the Song of Songs. For most of Jewish and Christian history, the majority reading was allegory: a poem about God and Israel, or Christ and the church, using the language of human romance. In roughly the last two centuries, most scholars, including most evangelical scholars, have read it literally, as a celebration of romantic and erotic love between a man and a woman. The lecture says readers will not agree here, and the course does not settle it.

Key idea A course that quietly favored one side would do justice to neither tradition.
Allegory

The reading most interpreters held

In Judaism the Song was read as the covenant love between God and Israel from the early rabbinic period. Rabbi Akiva is reported to have called it the holy of holies among the Writings. Christian interpreters such as Origen and Gregory of Nyssa read it as Christ and the church, or Christ and the believer's soul. Bernard of Clairvaux preached eighty-six sermons on just its first two chapters. This reading stayed dominant through the Reformation.

Key idea Its defenders say dismissing it dismisses centuries of serious thinkers.
Allegory's argument

The marriage metaphor is already in Scripture

The allegorical reading's strongest argument is not only its age. Scripture already uses marriage as an image for God's relationship to his people, without the Song's help. The lecture lists Hosea and Gomer, Isaiah 54:5, Ezekiel 16, Jeremiah 2, Ephesians 5:25-32 and the marriage supper of the Lamb in Revelation 19:7-9. On this view, the Song is where that image gets its most sustained poetic treatment.

Key idea Reading the Song this way continues a canonical metaphor, not an outside imposition.
Literal reading

Reading the words in their own genre

Tremper Longman III argues that nothing in the Song signals allegory the way Ezekiel 16 or Hosea 1-3 do, since those passages name Israel and Yahweh and the Song never does. Richard Davidson points to the Song's detailed language: the wasf praising the body, the garden as a figure for the woman, and the desire for physical presence. He argues that allegory has sometimes come at the cost of treating the body and marriage as good gifts of creation. Both ground the poem in Genesis 1-2 and its "one flesh" union (Genesis 2:24).

Key idea On this view the Song needs no allegory to be serious Scripture.
At a glance

Each side's sharpest objection to the other

Literal against allegory

Allegorists sometimes assigned meaning to details the text does not mark. Bernard, for example, found extended spiritual meanings in individual body features of the wasf passages. If nothing signals "read this as code," the method can find whatever the interpreter brings.

Allegory against literal

If the Song is only a poem about two anonymous lovers, its place in the canon is harder to explain. Why would this love poem and not others from the ancient world be inspired? Its canonicity suggests early readers saw more than human love.

One verse

"A very flame of Yahweh" at 8:6

This phrase (Hebrew shalhevetyah) is very likely the only place the divine name appears in the Song, and even that is disputed. The ending -yah could invoke the name, or it could be an intensifying suffix, like "a raging inferno" in English. The allegorical tradition takes it as confirming the poem was always reaching beyond human romance. The literal tradition reads it as the fierce peak oath of a love poem, needing no allegorical referent.

Key idea Both sides appeal to the same line, and grammarians are divided.
A middle path

A third option and where scholarship stands

Some recent scholarship proposes that the Song truly celebrates human love at the literal level. That celebration then serves, through canonical placement and Scripture's wider marriage imagery, as a fitting analogy for divine love, without decoding every verse. The lecture says this is not a fully worked-out third position. It has not displaced either major view, and the course does not present it as a resolution.

Key idea The shift from allegory to literalism is not necessarily the last word.
Think about it

A marriage image that is never named

Hosea, Ezekiel 16 and Ephesians 5 use marriage as an image for God and his people without leaving the reader to guess. The Song, on any reading, never makes that identification explicit.

What do you make of the fact that the Song never states that identification explicitly?

Remember

If you remember nothing else

The Song has been read two ways. The allegorical reading, from Rabbi Akiva to Bernard and through the Reformation, sees God's love for Israel or Christ's for the church, and leans on Scripture's marriage metaphor. The literal reading, held by Longman, Davidson and most modern scholars, sees a celebration of human love rooted in Genesis 1-2. Song 8:6 is claimed by both and settled by neither. The course does not decide between them.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12