Lecture 3-1: Source Criticism and the Shared Material of the Synoptic Gospels
Matthew, Mark and Luke agree too closely to be coincidence
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Matthew, Mark and Luke agree too closely to be coincidence
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
A "synopsis" comes from the Greek for "seeing together." It means reading Matthew, Mark and Luke side by side. Doing so shows that large stretches share not only events but sentence structure, word order and even rare Greek vocabulary. Independent writers do not produce that kind of agreement by chance, so at least one Gospel used another, or all three drew on shared earlier material, written or oral.
Source criticism asks what earlier material, oral or written, lies behind a text and how the author used it. Almost no scholar of any theological view denies that Matthew, Mark and Luke are related. The question is how. This lecture shows the phenomenon, and the Synoptic Problem proper, meaning which solution best explains it, is left for chapter 4.
Three people reporting separately on one teacher would agree on the outline but differ in wording, order and detail. The Synoptics show something different: whole passages that agree in exact phrasing. Matthew 24:15 and Mark 13:14 both pause with the same aside addressed to the reader, "let the reader understand." The lecture says that is not the sign of independent eyewitness memory but of a literary relationship.
Found in all three Gospels: much of the passion narrative, many miracles and a large share of Mark's content.
Found in Matthew and Luke but not Mark, largely sayings, including much of the Sermon on the Mount and Luke's Sermon on the Plain.
Luke's Prodigal Son and Good Samaritan, and Matthew's magi and flight to Egypt.
Mark is the shortest of the three Gospels by a wide margin. The great majority of Mark's content reappears, in some form, in Matthew, Luke or both. The lecture calls this an observation, not yet an argument for any solution. Any adequate account of how the Gospels relate has to explain it.
Luke tells Theophilus that many had already undertaken to set in order a narrative about Jesus. He does not name those accounts, and none survive independently for us to compare. He says he traced the course of all things accurately from the first and set it down in order. So source criticism is not an idea forced on the text by suspicious modern scholars. The lecture says the existence of earlier written material is not seriously in dispute, because Luke says so.
Formal source-critical study of the Synoptics is usually dated to Johann Jakob Griesbach's 1776 synopsis. It printed Matthew, Mark and Luke in parallel columns so the pattern of agreement could be seen at a glance. Griesbach's own solution put Matthew first, then Luke, with Mark last. The lecture says his tool outlived his answer, and later proposals all depend on the same side-by-side comparison.
This lecture does not say which Gospel came first or whether a lost sayings source called Q existed. Careful scholars disagree on all three questions.
Why might it matter to see the underlying pattern clearly before choosing a preferred solution? What would be lost by skipping straight to an answer?
Matthew, Mark and Luke agree in exact wording, word order and even editorial asides. That is too close for independent memory and too patterned for coincidence. Source criticism sorts the shared material into triple tradition, double tradition and material found in one Gospel only, without yet deciding which Gospel came first. Luke's preface confirms that earlier written sources existed, and chapter 4 takes up the Synoptic Problem in full.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.