Lecture 3-3: Evangelical and Canonical Responses to Critical Method
Using historical tools without adopting their most skeptical premises
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Using historical tools without adopting their most skeptical premises
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Source, form and redaction criticism can leave an impression that the Gospels' compositional history sits in tension with their claim to be trustworthy testimony. The lecture says this is not inevitable. Real human authors making real editorial choices does not by itself mean they were unreliable. Two influential responses, from Brevard Childs and N.T. Wright, refuse to treat historical method and theological confidence as a forced choice.
Brevard Childs, who taught at Yale, noted that historical-critical work had spent a century reconstructing layers behind a biblical text. He argued that treating that prehistory as more important than the text as it stands is backwards. The church confesses faith in the text it received, the canonical form, which is also the only form anyone can read, check and hold the church accountable to. He did not reject historical study, but said the theological payoff belongs to the finished text read as Scripture.
N.T. Wright, an Anglican bishop and New Testament historian, describes his approach as critical realism, aimed at how historical knowledge works. It sits between naive realism, which assumes a historian can simply read off what happened, and a thorough skepticism that says no real knowledge of the past is available. A critical realist proposes hypotheses and tests them for simplicity, for how much of the evidence they explain and for how well they make sense of puzzling details. Wright says his method leads him to more confidence in the Gospels' basic reliability than Bultmann had.
Asks where meaning is located: in the finished, received text, not in a reconstructed layer behind it.
Asks how historical knowledge works: between naive positivism and radical skepticism, by testing hypotheses against the evidence.
Childs was not a confessional evangelical by most definitions, and he drew real criticism from evangelical scholars for parts of his method. Wright's historical work on Jesus has been criticized by more traditionally conservative scholars for conceding too much, and by more skeptical scholars for conceding too little. What the two share is a refusal of one false choice. Taking the Gospels' compositional history seriously does not require giving up confidence that the finished text is trustworthy testimony.
Paul says every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, reproof, correction and instruction. The lecture notes what the verse does not do by itself. It does not specify a mechanism of composition, rule out an evangelist's use of earlier sources, or decide which solution to the Synoptic Problem is correct. Its claim is about Scripture's God-breathed character and usefulness, which leaves space that the canonical approach and critical realism try to fill responsibly.
Childs located theological authority in the finished text rather than in a reconstructed history behind it. The lecture presents this as one serious option and does not require the student to accept it.
What do you find attractive, or unsatisfying, about locating theological authority in the finished text instead of a reconstructed history?
Childs moves theological authority to the canonical text the church received, and Wright's critical realism steers between naive positivism and radical skepticism. Both refuse the idea that historical method and confidence in Scripture must be opposed. 2 Timothy 3:16 calls Scripture God-breathed but does not specify or rule out any process of composition. The chapter gave no verdict on contested questions. It set out the tools and two responsible ways of using them.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.