FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT501E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-3: The Ending of Mark

Mark 16:9-20 is a genuinely disputed ending; the empty tomb is not

Introduction to the New Testament

11 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State which major early manuscripts lack Mark 16:9-20, and which manuscripts and versions contain it.
  • Describe the "shorter ending" as a third textual option distinct from both 16:8 and the traditional longer ending.
  • Summarize at least two proposed explanations for why Mark might end at 16:8, and at least two arguments for why 16:9-20 might be original or nearly so.
  • Explain why this question connects back to chapter 1's discussion of the New Testament's manuscript evidence, rather than standing apart from it.
  • Describe what is theologically at stake in the choice, and what remains true about Mark's Gospel regardless of how the question is resolved.
Starting point

A famous textual question

The last twelve verses of Mark, printed in most English Bibles as 16:9-20, are absent from the two oldest and generally most respected Greek manuscripts of the New Testament. They are also missing from several other early witnesses. Without them, Mark ends at 16:8 on a note of fear and silence, with no resurrection appearance narrated. This is one of the largest and most disputed textual questions in the New Testament, and even scholars with a very high view of Scripture land in different places.

Key idea This is not a routine variant; it is a real, open dispute.
At a glance

Three endings in the manuscripts

Ends at 16:8

The reading of Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus, both from the fourth century, plus an Old Latin manuscript and portions of the Sinaitic Syriac. Eusebius and Jerome report it was absent from most Greek copies they knew.

The shorter ending

A brief, stylistically different conclusion in a handful of manuscripts. It shows early scribes were not comfortable leaving the Gospel at 16:8.

The longer ending, 16:9-20

Found in the overwhelming majority of Greek manuscripts, including Codex Alexandrinus and the Byzantine tradition, and known as early as the second century. It narrates appearances, the Great Commission and the ascension.

Evidence

Why most textual critics doubt 16:9-20

The vocabulary and style of 16:9-20 differ noticeably from the rest of Mark. It uses a different Greek word for "arose," for instance, and has words and phrases found nowhere else in the Gospel. Bruce Metzger judged the external evidence against it exceptionally strong, and treated the longer ending as a later addition by someone other than Mark. Most textual critics, across a range of theological commitments, agree, though not universally.

Key idea A wide but not universal consensus.
Puzzle

A book that ends on the word "for"

In Greek, verse 8 ends with the conjunction *gar* ("for"). That is unusual, though not unattested, and many readers have felt it is an incomplete sentence. Some scholars propose that Mark's original final page was lost very early, so the true ending is not preserved in any witness. Others think Mark meant to stop at 16:8.

Key idea Two explanations for an abrupt ending: lost, or deliberate.
Two readings

Meant to stop, or meant to continue?

16:8 is deliberate

The abruptness fits the Gospel's pattern of delayed, frightened recognition. It leaves the reader, who already knows the truth, to respond with something other than silence. Mark also leaves other scenes unresolved, such as the young man who flees in 14:51-52.

16:9-20 is original or received

A minority points to its early and widespread attestation, its long use in worship, and the belief that God preserved the church's received text. Some simply doubt any author would end a Gospel on "for."

The lecture's stance

The course does not adjudicate between them. Careful, well-informed readers differ.

Perspective

What is not at stake

No manuscript of Mark denies the resurrection. The angel's announcement in 16:6, "He has risen," is in every textual tradition. What is disputed is only whether Mark himself narrates a resurrection appearance. The material in 16:9-20 is paralleled elsewhere: Mary Magdalene echoes John 20, the Emmaus-like appearance echoes Luke 24, and the Great Commission echoes Matthew 28.

Key idea The dispute is about how the news was first told, not whether Christ rose.
Think about it

If Mark ends at 16:8

If Mark did end at 16:8, the Gospel's earlier pattern of the messianic secret and the disciples' repeated failure to understand reaches one more instance: the women flee in fear and say nothing.

If Mark intended to end at 16:8, how would that fit, or not fit, with the pattern of hidden identity and misunderstanding traced in the earlier lectures?

Recap

What to carry forward

Mark 16:9-20 is missing from the oldest and best Greek manuscripts, so without it Mark ends at 16:8 with the women fleeing in fear and silence. Bruce Metzger and most textual critics conclude it was added later by someone else. Other careful readers weigh its early and widespread attestation and still receive it as Mark's conclusion or as Scripture. Every manuscript agrees on 16:6: "He has risen. He is not here." The disagreement is only about how, and by whom, the rest of the news was first told.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11