FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT501E · Chapter 9

Lecture 9-1: The Quests — Old, No Quest, and Third

The quest for the historical Jesus has its own history

Introduction to the New Testament

12 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what scholars mean by "the historical Jesus" as a technical term, distinct from "the real Jesus."
  • Summarize Hermann Reimarus's argument and why it is usually treated as the beginning of the quest.
  • State Rudolf Bultmann's position on how much of Jesus's life can be historically recovered, and why he did not think that mattered as much for Christian faith as it might seem.
  • Name at least two features that distinguish the Third Quest from the periods before it.
  • Explain why this lecture calls the "No Quest" label somewhat misleading.
Starting point

What "the historical Jesus" means

"The historical Jesus" is a scholarly construct. It names whatever can be established about Jesus of Nazareth using the ordinary methods historians apply to any ancient figure, such as cross-checking sources and weighing how close they are to the events. It is a claim about method, not about reality. History can only reach what its methods can reach, and those methods were never designed to judge a claim like the resurrection.

Key idea It does not mean "the real Jesus" as opposed to a fake one.
Old Quest

Reimarus and the birth of the question

The quest is usually dated to essays by the German scholar Hermann Samuel Reimarus (1694-1768), published by Gotthold Lessing beginning in 1774. Reimarus argued for a sharp line between what Jesus himself intended and what the disciples later claimed about him. On his reading, Jesus led a failed political-messianic movement, and the disciples' claims were their own theological invention. He was the first to insist in print that "the Jesus of history" and "the Christ preached by the church" might be two different things.

Key idea The question began as a deliberate provocation.
Old Quest

Schweitzer: finding a mirror

The nineteenth century produced many "lives of Jesus" that stripped away what their authors judged to be later theological additions. Albert Schweitzer's 1906 survey, The Quest of the Historical Jesus, argued that nearly all of them had reconstructed a Jesus who looked like the scholar's own preferences. His critique became a lasting warning: a reader can find a mirror rather than a stranger.

Key idea Be careful when the Jesus you find looks just like you.
No Quest

Bultmann's skepticism

From roughly the 1920s to the 1950s, confidence fell. Rudolf Bultmann held that the Gospels were shaped so thoroughly by the early church, and passed on by oral tradition for decades, that very little about the historical figure could be recovered. We can know that Jesus existed and was crucified, and little else with real certainty. The lecture says the label "No Quest" overstates the case, since serious scholarship on Jesus continued.

Key idea What changed in this period was confidence, not interest.
No Quest

Faith and the kerygma

Bultmann did not treat this uncertainty as a crisis for faith. He argued that faith responds to the church's proclamation (the kerygma, the message about the crucified and risen Christ), not to a biography built by scholars. Not every scholar accepts this. Many argue that Christian faith does make historical claims, that Jesus lived, taught, died and was raised, which cannot simply be kept apart from historical study.

Key idea Bultmann's separation of faith and history is still disputed.
Third Quest

Renewed confidence, different tools

Beginning roughly in the 1980s, the Third Quest rejected the pessimism of the No Quest period. It drew on richer knowledge of Second Temple Judaism (the Judaism of the period when the Temple stood), on archaeology and on the social history of first-century Galilee. Its working assumption is that placing Jesus firmly in first-century Palestinian Judaism is the most promising path to reconstruction.

Key idea "A first-century Jew" is the most secure starting point.
At a glance

Three phases of the quest

Old Quest

Reimarus and the "lives of Jesus"; Schweitzer's critique that each found a mirror.

No Quest

Bultmann's skepticism: little can be recovered, and faith rests on the kerygma, not on reconstruction.

Third Quest

Jesus read within Second Temple Judaism, with diverse conclusions among its scholars.

Think about it

Is the mirror danger only old?

Schweitzer's critique was that the Old Quest's authors kept finding a Jesus who resembled their own cultural moment.

Is that danger unique to the nineteenth century, or does it apply just as much to scholars working today, including in the Third Quest?

Recap

What to carry forward

The quest for the historical Jesus has three phases that reacted to one another. Reimarus split the Jesus of history from the Christ of faith, and Schweitzer showed that the "lives of Jesus" kept finding a mirror. Bultmann's skepticism held that little could be recovered, yet argued that faith rests on the church's proclamation. The Third Quest rejected that pessimism by reading Jesus within first-century Judaism. None of the three phases has simply been erased by the next.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12