Lecture 9-3: Contemporary Approaches — The Jesus Seminar and the Third Quest
Two serious camps read the same evidence and disagree
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Two serious camps read the same evidence and disagree
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Two contemporary camps read much of the same first-century evidence and reach different conclusions about how much of the Gospels' portrait historical method can confirm. One is the Jesus Seminar, associated with Robert Funk and John Dominic Crossan. The other is often grouped under the Third Quest label, represented by N.T. Wright and James Dunn. Both are described as real, serious scholarship, and neither is presented as the course's own settled answer.
Robert Funk founded the Jesus Seminar in 1985. Its scholars voted with colored beads on how likely it was that a saying or deed originated with Jesus: red for almost certainly authentic, black for almost certainly not, pink and gray for degrees between. The Seminar also treated the non-canonical Gospel of Thomas as a possibly independent early source. In The Five Gospels (1993), it judged only about one saying in five likely authentic in anything close to its recorded form.
Funk argued that scholars should share their findings with the wider public. He thought the church's portrait of Jesus had gathered later theological overlay. Using something close to a strict version of dissimilarity and form-critical judgments, the Seminar pictured an itinerant, subversive wisdom teacher rather than the apocalyptic, miracle-working, messianic figure of the full Gospel narrative. Later followers, on this view, layered supernatural and messianic claims onto a modest original.
In The Historical Jesus (1991), John Dominic Crossan combined the saying-by-saying method with the social history of Galilean peasant life. His Jesus is a Jewish Cynic-like sage who practices "open commensality", meaning table fellowship without regard to social status, and "brokerless" access to God that bypassed the Temple's authority. On Crossan's reading, Jesus was crucified for confronting Roman and Temple power. The lecture calls his work careful and extensively researched, not casual skepticism.
N.T. Wright argues, especially in Jesus and the Victory of God (1996), that the Seminar's method underweights first-century Jewish apocalyptic expectation. He places Jesus within Israel's story of exile, hoped-for restoration and the coming reign of God. The Temple demonstration, the choice of twelve disciples and the charge "King of the Jews" make sense, he argues, as coherent actions of someone claiming a climactic role in that story. He says he uses ordinary historical method.
In Jesus Remembered (2003), James Dunn draws on studies of oral tradition in traditional societies. He argues that material valued by a community is preserved with more stability than a "broken telephone" picture assumes. On his account, differences in wording between parallel Gospel accounts are a normal feature of oral tradition, not mainly a sign of unreliable transmission. If he is right, there is more reason for confidence in the Gospels' overall portrait.
Wright gives it a great deal of weight; the Jesus Seminar generally treats apocalyptic material as a later addition.
Dunn argues for real stability; the Seminar's method assumes more instability and theological reshaping.
The Seminar gave it substantial weight; Wright, Dunn and many others judge it later and more dependent on the canonical tradition.
The lecture notes that the bead-vote method has been criticized even by scholars with no theological stake, and that Wright's and Dunn's conclusions are contested by other Third Quest historians.
Why might it matter, when judging this debate fairly, to know that each side has real critics within the field?
The Jesus Seminar judged about one Gospel saying in five authentic and pictured Jesus as an itinerant wisdom teacher. Wright and Dunn argue for much greater confidence, reading Jesus within Israel's story and trusting oral tradition's stability. The real disagreement is not scholarship versus faith. It concerns three nameable points: apocalyptic weight, oral tradition's stability and the Gospel of Thomas. Neither side has won the field.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.