Lecture 12-3: Romans and the New Perspective on Paul
Two readings of "works of the law" in Romans
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Two readings of "works of the law" in Romans
Introduction to the New Testament
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
The New Perspective on Paul was flagged as a live debate in the introduction to Paul's letters and is engaged more fully elsewhere in the course, especially for Galatians. This lecture's task is narrower: how the debate's central claims bear on Romans, where justification by faith and works of the law get their fullest Pauline development. Both readings agree that Paul contrasts works with faith and grace. They disagree about what kind of works he mainly has in view.
Since the Reformation, the majority reading has taken Paul to oppose any human attempt to establish righteousness before God by moral or ritual performance. This fits Romans 1-3, where no one is justified by works of the law because all have sinned. On this reading, Romans 4:4-5, the contrast between a wage owed and a gift credited to one who does not work, speaks about human effort and merit as such, illustrated by, but not limited to, the Jewish law.
D.A. Carson and Peter O'Brien edited the project Justification and Variegated Nomism. They defended a version of this reading with a wide survey of Second Temple Jewish texts. They argued that a real strand of merit-based thought is documented there, even if it was not the only strand. On their account, Paul's polemic is a fair engagement with views some Second Temple Jews held, not a caricature invented by later Christian readers.
E.P. Sanders's 1977 study Paul and Palestinian Judaism argued that the older Protestant picture of first-century Judaism as legalistic merit-earning was largely a caricature. He proposed "covenantal nomism": one enters the covenant by God's grace and election, and the law maintains membership in a people already graciously chosen. If he is right, Paul cannot simply be opposing a religion of earning salvation, so something else must be the real target of his argument.
N.T. Wright builds on Sanders and argues that in Paul, "righteousness" carries covenant-faithfulness meaning, and "justification" partly declares who belongs to God's covenant family. On this reading, the works of the law Paul rejects are mainly the identity-marking practices of circumcision, food laws and Sabbath, when treated as the boundary of who belongs to God's people. Wright reads Romans 3:27-30 as saying that one God justifies the circumcised and the uncircumcised on the same terms.
Traditional: boasting in one's own moral achievement, and Abraham rules out earning by any works. New Perspective: boasting in covenant status marked by law and circumcision, and Abraham, justified before circumcision, shows Gentiles need not take on that badge.
Traditional: Israel pursued self-earned righteousness through law-keeping. New Perspective: Israel insisted on a national, ethnically bounded righteousness and resisted extending the law to Gentiles on faith terms.
Both readings claim real exegetical and historical support and have been revised across decades, with disagreement inside each camp. Sanders's description has been both defended and qualified. Some traditional interpreters think Wright understates the individual, forensic side of justification in Romans 4-5, while some New Perspective interpreters think he keeps too many traditional categories. Carson and O'Brien's survey has drawn replies that it underweights covenantal-grace material.
Whichever reading you prefer, both sides see Romans 4:4-5 as central: a reward owed set against a gift credited to one who simply believes.
What would you need to see in Romans 3:27-4:5 to decide whether "boasting" means moral achievement or covenant status?
Sanders argued that Second Temple Judaism was covenantal nomism rather than merit-earning legalism, and Wright developed this into the claim that works of the law mean Jewish ethnic boundary markers. Carson and O'Brien defend the traditional reading, which sees self-earned righteousness in general. The two readings diverge over Romans 3:27-4:5 and 9:30-32 but agree that Romans 4:4-5 is central. The course takes no side.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.