FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT501E · Chapter 26

Lecture 26-1: Who Wrote 2 Peter?

Who wrote 2 Peter? The hardest authorship case, with evidence on both sides

Introduction to the New Testament

13 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the critical case against Petrine authorship of 2 Peter, including its strongest specific evidence, without caricaturing it.
  • State the traditional defense of Petrine authorship, including its strongest specific evidence, without caricaturing it.
  • Explain why 2 Peter's early external attestation differs from that of most other New Testament books, and why that fact alone does not settle the question either way.
  • Identify what is actually at stake, historically and theologically, in how a reader resolves this question — and what remains true about the letter regardless of which way it is resolved.
Starting point

The hardest case in the New Testament

Many New Testament introductions say that 2 Peter is the hardest authorship case in the book. That is the view of a wide range of scholars, including many who hold a high view of Scripture's inspiration. This lecture does not tell you what to conclude. It gives the evidence on both sides, stated as strongly as its own supporters state it.

Key idea You should be able to explain either side fairly to someone who holds the other.
Scripture

Why 2 Peter 1:1?

The lecture begins with what the letter says about itself. It opens in Peter's name and voice, and any account of its origin has to explain more than this bare name.

Simon Peter, a servant and apostle of Jesus Christ, to those who have obtained a like precious faith with us in the righteousness of our God and Savior, Jesus Christ. 2 Peter 1:1, World English Bible
The claim

An unusually specific self-claim

The author does not merely open with a name. He claims to know his death is near (1:14) and to have been present at the Transfiguration. He also mentions an earlier letter (3:1) and calls Paul "our beloved brother" (3:15). If the letter is not from Peter, it is not a case of an anonymous disciple writing in a teacher's tradition. It is a specific claim to firsthand experience made by someone other than the person named.

Key idea Any account of 2 Peter has to explain all of these claims.
Scripture

Why 2 Peter 1:16?

The lecture uses this verse as the centre of the letter's eyewitness claim to the Transfiguration, the claim it keeps returning to.

For we did not follow cunningly devised fables, when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty. 2 Peter 1:16, WEB
Critical case

Four lines of evidence against Peter's authorship

First, the Greek is more ornate than 1 Peter, and 2 Peter names no secretary. Second, about nineteen of Jude's twenty-five verses have a close parallel in 2 Peter, and most scholars think 2 Peter is the borrower. Third, no surviving writer clearly quotes 2 Peter before the third century, and Eusebius lists it among the antilegomena, the "spoken-against" books. Fourth, the scoffers in 3:4 and the collected letters of Paul in 3:15-16 seem to fit a later setting. On this view the letter is a pseudepigraphon, written in Peter's name after his death.

Key idea Critical scholars include moderate and some evangelical scholars, not only skeptics.
Traditional defense

Answers to each point

Defenders of authenticity, such as Michael Green and Carson and Moo, say that the emphatic eyewitness claim is not easy to set aside. In their view, a false claim would be a specific fabrication of eyewitness testimony. They say a secretary with real freedom can explain the style. Using Jude's letter is no more beneath an apostle than a later imitator. A short letter with narrow circulation could plausibly be accepted more slowly.

Key idea Both sides answer the other's strongest points.
At a glance

Style, Jude, attestation and setting

Style

Critical view: no named secretary explains the gap. Traditional view: a freer secretary, perhaps near Peter's death, explains it.

Jude

Critical view: heavy dependence is hard for an apostle. Traditional view: using Jude's material shows only that the author knew Jude's letter.

Attestation

Critical view: no clear citation before Origen, who records a dispute. Traditional view: a short letter circulates more slowly, yet the whole church finally accepted it.

What is at stake

Two careful conclusions

Neither side is a fringe position, and neither is dishonest to the evidence. A student who has only heard the traditional case has not been told that the early church argued about this letter openly. A student who has only heard the critical case has not been told that 2 Peter makes an eyewitness claim unlike almost anything else in the canon, and that a real cost attaches to setting it aside.

Key idea This is not an easy call in either direction.
Think about it

Answering a congregation

What both sides can affirm is that the church received 2 Peter as canonical Scripture, and its argument stands or falls on its own content.

If a congregation asked you, "Did Peter really write this?", how would you answer honestly about the uncertainty without leaving the impression that the letter's authority is in doubt?

Recap

What to carry forward

2 Peter is the hardest authorship case because it combines an unusually specific eyewitness claim with the latest and most contested outside attestation of any New Testament book. The critical case and the traditional defense each answer the other point by point, and this course does not declare either fully settled. Both sides agree that the whole church received the letter as canonical Scripture.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13