FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT606E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-1: Form Criticism: Gunkel, Mowinckel, and After

Gunkel changed the question from which moment in David's life a psalm records to what kind of poem it is and what recurring situation it serves.

The Poetic and Wisdom Books

13 cards 23 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what Hermann Gunkel meant by Gattung and Sitz im Leben, and state how this reframed the question interpreters ask of a psalm.
  • List Gunkel's main psalm types and give one example of each.
  • Explain how Sigmund Mowinckel extended Gunkel's categories toward an actual cultic setting, and state one standing criticism of that extension.
  • Identify at least two ways a specific, named psalm resists the taxonomy, and explain what that resistance implies about how the categories should be used.
  • State Erhard Gerstenberger's alternative proposal about where many individual laments actually originated, and what kind of evidence he appeals to.
Before Gunkel

The psalm as a piece of biography

For a long time the standard question about a psalm was biographical: which moment in David's life does it record? Thirteen psalms carry a heading that names such an incident, so for those the question is reasonable. The other psalms give no anchor, and commentators proposed many different occasions that could never be checked. The only evidence was the psalm's own wording, which fits many different lives.

Key idea A method that cannot be checked against outside evidence cannot be built on.
Gunkel's move

Gattung and Sitz im Leben

Hermann Gunkel asked two linked questions. What Gattung (genre, or literary type) does the poem belong to, judged by its recurring forms? And what Sitz im Leben ("setting in life") would call such a poem into being? A lament is not a report of one catastrophe. It is what is said whenever a person or a people meets the kind of trouble laments are made for.

Key idea The question moved from one unrepeatable event to a repeatable pattern.
Gunkel's main types

The working vocabulary

Praise and thanks

Hymns of praise celebrate who God is and what God has done. Thanksgiving songs tell of a specific rescue already accomplished.

Laments

Individual laments are a person's cry in distress, the largest group in the Psalter. Communal laments are the same cry voiced by the whole people.

Other types

Royal psalms are tied to the king. Songs of trust are calm affirmations. Wisdom psalms are instructional. Songs of ascents belong to the journey to the temple.

Scripture

Why Psalms 13:1-4?

The lecture uses these verses to show the shape of an individual lament before any label is attached. Verses 1-2 are complaint, and verses 3-4 turn to direct request.

How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?
How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?
Behold, and answer me, Yahweh, my God. Give light to my eyes, lest I sleep in death;
Lest my enemy say, “I have prevailed against him”; Lest my adversaries rejoice when I fall. Psalms 13:1-4 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Psalms 100:1-3?

The lecture sets this psalm beside Psalm 13 to show the contrasting shape of a hymn. It opens with plural commands to praise and then gives a reason for praise.

Shout for joy to Yahweh, all you lands!
Serve Yahweh with gladness. Come before his presence with singing.
Know that Yahweh, he is God. It is he who has made us, and we are his. We are his people, and the sheep of his pasture. Psalms 100:1-3 · WEB
Mowinckel

From a general setting to a specific occasion

Sigmund Mowinckel pressed the setting question further than Gunkel. He argued that many psalms were made for particular moments in the temple's worship calendar. The text of a psalm rarely names its own occasion, so critics say the ritual calendar must be brought in from comparative Near Eastern material. Even scholars close to Gunkel's tradition, such as Hans-Joachim Kraus, accepted parts of this program and resisted others.

Key idea Almost no one denies the temple shaped the Psalter. The dispute is how exactly an occasion can be named.
Where the boxes break

Psalm 89 and Psalm 34

The categories are not a filing system with one drawer for each psalm. Psalm 89 begins as a royal psalm about God's promise to David's line, then turns into a sharp communal lament about that promise. Psalm 34 is an acrostic that opens with thanksgiving and from about verse 11 shifts into instruction like Proverbs. Neither is a defect in the psalm. Each shows that the categories describe tendencies, not sealed compartments.

Key idea Real poems combine and bend the types.
Gerstenberger

Questioning the temple as the default

Erhard Gerstenberger argues that many individual laments show no sign of needing a priest, a sanctuary or an official liturgy. Using comparative studies of healing and complaint rituals in families and small groups, he proposes a household or kin-group setting. His evidence is indirect: most laments lack markers that would require an institutional setting. The state of the field is a live argument about how much the text can bear.

Key idea The question of where a psalm was used has more than one defensible answer.
Think about it

Method and its limits

This lecture teaches the method together with the places where its own categories fail.

Why might it help a reader to learn the categories and also see where real psalms resist them?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Ask what kind of poem a psalm is and what recurring situation it serves, instead of guessing one biographical event. The categories describe tendencies, not sealed boxes. Mowinckel's temple occasions and Gerstenberger's household settings both rest on indirect evidence.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13