Sigmund Mowinckel pressed the setting question further than Gunkel. He argued that many psalms were made for particular moments in the temple's worship calendar. The text of a psalm rarely names its own occasion, so critics say the ritual calendar must be brought in from comparative Near Eastern material. Even scholars close to Gunkel's tradition, such as Hans-Joachim Kraus, accepted parts of this program and resisted others.
Key idea Almost no one denies the temple shaped the Psalter. The dispute is how exactly an occasion can be named.