FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT606E · Chapter 12

Lecture 12-2: Allegory, and Why It Ruled for Two Thousand Years

For about two thousand years the Song of Songs was read as a book about God's love, and that reading was the main reading, not a side path.

The Poetic and Wisdom Books

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Rabbi Akiva's declaration about the Song of Songs and explain what it tells us about the book's status in early Jewish reading.
  • Describe how the Targum on the Song reads the book, and name at least two Christian readers — from at least two different centuries — who read it allegorically, stating what each one's reading emphasized.
  • Narrate the dispute between Sebastian Castellio and John Calvin over the Song's canonical status and genre, and explain what was actually at stake in it.
  • Give at least two concrete historical reasons the majority scholarly reading shifted toward the literal sense after roughly 1800.
  • State the allegorical method's principal weakness honestly, without treating the tradition as therefore worthless or closed.
The tradition

Allegory was the reading

For most of Jewish and Christian history the Song was read as a book about the love between God and Israel, Christ and the church, or God and the soul. This was not a minority reading added to excuse an awkward text. Some of the deepest devotional writing in the Christian tradition came from it, including Origen, Bernard of Clairvaux and John of the Cross.

Key idea The lecture takes this history seriously and does not explain it away.
Scripture

Why Song of Solomon 8:6?

The lecture calls this the book's most extravagant claim about love. It also notes that the divine name appears in the Song in only two places, and that most commentators read the phrase here as an intensifier.

Set me as a seal on your heart, as a seal on your arm; for love is strong as death. Jealousy is as cruel as Sheol. Its flashes are flashes of fire, a very flame of Yahweh. Song of Solomon 8:6 · World English Bible
Jewish roots

Rabbi Akiva and the Targum

The Mishnah preserves Rabbi Akiva's saying that the Song is the 'holy of holies' among the writings. He said it while defending the book's status, so its canonicity was not simply assumed. The Targum, an Aramaic paraphrase with commentary, reads the whole book as a historical allegory. The woman is the congregation of Israel, the man is God, and images match events like the exodus and Sinai.

Key idea Christian interpreters adapted a pattern that already existed.
Scripture

Why Song of Solomon 1:2?

The lecture uses this verse as a worked example. The Targum reads the kiss as Israel's longing for direct revelation of the law, and Bernard's sermons use the same line to meditate on kinds of intimacy with God.

Let him kiss me with the kisses of his mouth; for your love is better than wine. Song of Solomon 1:2 · WEB
At a glance

Four Christian readers

Origen (3rd century)

The bridegroom is Christ, the bride is the church or the individual soul.

Gregory of Nyssa (4th century)

The soul's endless approach to an infinite God, called epektasis.

Bernard of Clairvaux (12th century)

Eighty-six sermons to his monks that reach only chapter 3.

John of the Cross (16th century)

The Spiritual Canticle, using the Song's imagery for the soul's dark night and union with God.

A dispute

Castellio and Calvin

In Geneva in the early 1540s, Sebastian Castellio held that the Song was a secular love poem, and he questioned whether it belonged in the canon. Calvin regarded this as a serious error and opposed Castellio's ordination partly on this ground. Other disagreements were also involved, and Castellio left Geneva. The lecture says this does not show that the Reformers dropped allegory, since most Protestant commentators of the time still read the Song as about Christ.

Key idea Here a literal reading was treated as dangerous, not merely mistaken.
The shift

Why scholars moved to the literal sense after 1800

The lecture gives three reasons. Historical-critical method asks what a text meant to its ancient audience. Ancient Near Eastern love poetry, including the Egyptian songs, made the Song's content look ordinary as love poetry. A wider cultural change also made human love seem worthy of serious attention in its own right.

Key idea No single reason explains the shift.
An honest limit

The method has little internal control

Allegory has almost no built-in check on which correspondences a reader may find. Two equally devout readers can reach incompatible readings of the same verse. The literal reading's advantage is that it can be tested against the plain words and comparative evidence. The lecture says naming this does not make Akiva, Origen, Bernard or John of the Cross worthless.

Key idea Their readings are devotional and theological constructions built on the text.
One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Allegory was the main reading in Jewish and Christian tradition, and it produced great devotional writing that remains alive in Catholic and Orthodox life. The lecture names the lack of control as a real weakness without calling the tradition closed or worthless.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12