FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

BT606E · Chapter 12

Lecture 12-3: Body, Desire, and What the Canon Does with This Book

A literal reading of the Song finds mutuality, a woman's initiative and no wedding, and it raises a question about how to teach a book about desire.

The Poetic and Wisdom Books

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Identify at least three features of the Song that a literal reading brings into focus — mutuality, the woman's initiative, and the absence of any wedding — and state why each is theologically significant rather than merely descriptive.
  • State Phyllis Trible's argument connecting Song of Songs 7:10 to Genesis 3:16, and explain in what sense she reads the Song as a reversal of the curse.
  • Present Marvin Pope's cultic and funerary hypothesis in its strongest form, and give at least two reasons most scholars have not adopted it.
  • Describe the specific pedagogical difficulty of teaching this book without retreating into allegory to avoid discomfort or reducing it to instruction in technique with the theology removed.
  • Articulate the closing question of this chapter — whether a text can sustain more than one true reading — in your own words, and take a position on it that you can defend.
Three features

What the literal reading brings into focus

The first feature is mutuality: the two voices praise each other's bodies in balanced terms, and neither commands while both invite. The second is the woman's initiative. She speaks first, searches for him at night and closes the book. The third is the absence of a wedding. The Song presents courtship and consummation without narrating a ceremony, and commentators disagree about how much weight that carries.

Key idea Each feature is a datum a careful reader must account for.
Scripture

Why Song of Solomon 7:10?

The lecture uses this verse as the woman's direct statement of mutual belonging in her own voice. It is also the verse on which Phyllis Trible builds her argument that the Song reverses Genesis 3:16.

I am my beloved’s. His desire is toward me. Song of Solomon 7:10 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Genesis 2:23-25?

The lecture uses this passage for the state of the garden before the fall, in which the man and woman were naked and not ashamed. Trible reads the Song's lovers as recovering that state.

The man said, “This is now bone of my bones, and flesh of my flesh. She will be called ‘woman,’ because she was taken out of Man.”
Therefore a man will leave his father and his mother, and will join with his wife, and they will be one flesh.
The man and his wife were both naked, and they were not ashamed. Genesis 2:23-25 · WEB
Trible

The Song as a reversal of Genesis 3

Genesis 3:16 says the woman's desire will be for her husband and that he will rule over her. Phyllis Trible reads the Song's 'his desire is toward me' as reversing that direction. The Song's garden evokes Eden restored, without hierarchy or shame. Critics say it depends on reading Genesis 2-3 and the Song as a deliberate pair, which cannot be proven from outside evidence.

Key idea A theological reading that does not require allegory.
At a glance

Two literal readings and their reception

Phyllis Trible (1978)

The Song undoes the distortion of Genesis 3. Widely influential, though it rests on internal echoes that readers weigh differently.

Marvin Pope (1977)

The Song has roots in funerary and fertility feasting, such as the marzeah. Not widely adopted.

Pope

Why most scholars did not follow Pope

The lecture presents Pope's case in its strongest form: wide comparative material, myrrh as an embalming spice, and the motif of a lover sought and not found. It gives three reasons it was not adopted. It relies on evidence drawn from many periods and cultures. Nothing in the Hebrew Bible links the Song with the marzeah. The Song itself reads as celebration, not mourning.

Key idea A serious argument can still fail to carry the field.
Teaching

The teacher's two temptations

One temptation is to retreat into allegory because a text about bodies makes a classroom uncomfortable. The other is to treat the Song as evidence for ancient customs or technique and drop its theological seriousness. The lecture says both are ways of not teaching the book that is actually there. A mature reading holds both facts: the plain sense is a poem in praise of embodied desire, and for most readers it has also spoken of the love of God.

Key idea Hold the plain sense and the long devotional history together.
Think about it

Rivals or partners

The lecture ends with a question and leaves it open.

Must the allegorical and literal readings be rivals, or can this book sustain both? Take a position and defend it from one reading in this lecture and one from the previous lecture.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The Song can be read as a poem of mutual, unashamed human love that also has theological weight. Trible argues it undoes the distortion of Genesis 3, but that is a literary judgment that cannot be proven. The lecture does not settle which reading is correct.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12