FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture

The apologists wrote back in the language of the people judging them. Justin and Tertullian defended the same faith in two incompatible ways, and the argument between them has never been settled.

Early Church History

12 cards 21 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what the apologists were for and state their two aims — clearing the rumours, and presenting Christianity as true philosophy — and assess how far they succeeded at each.
  • Explain Justin's logos Christology, including logos spermatikos, and how it reinterpreted Greek philosophy without simply endorsing it.
  • Explain what Tertullian meant by "What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?", and why his own practice does not match his slogan.
  • Apply the two approaches to the relationship between gospel and culture in a setting you know.
Writing back

A philosopher writes to the emperor

Around 155 a philosopher in Rome wrote to Antoninus Pius, arguing that Christians were being punished for a name. Justin held no office and had come to Christianity through Platonism. His letter did not work, and he was executed around 165. But he had done something new, which was to argue the church's case in public in the intellectual language of its judges.

Key idea The apologists wrote for outsiders, to emperors, governors and educated critics.
Scripture

Why 1 Peter 3:15?

The lecture uses this verse because the Greek word behind answer is apologia, a defence speech in a court, and it never meant apologising. The instruction is to argue, and to argue in a particular manner.

But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear." 1 Peter 3:15 · World English Bible
Two aims

Clear the rumours, show it is true

The apologists first answered the rumours: a meal about a body is not cannibalism, brother and sister is not incest, and declining your gods is not atheism. Their second aim was ambitious, to show that Christianity is true. To argue that to an educated Greek or Roman, you must use philosophy, and then decide whether philosophy is a road toward the truth or a rival to it.

Key idea Justin took the first answer. Tertullian took the second.
Justin

The seed of the Word

John calls Christ the Logos, and Logos was also a Greek philosophical term for the rational principle every human mind shares. Justin concluded that everyone who has reasoned truly has been in contact with Christ, and he named Socrates among them. He called this the logos spermatikos, the seed-bearing word. What the philosophers had in seed, Christians have whole, because the Logos became a particular man in a particular place.

Key idea The argument is generous and confident at once, but it risks turning Christianity into a philosophy.
Tertullian

The boundary

Tertullian of Carthage asked what Athens has to do with Jerusalem. He observed that every major heresy he could see had been imported from philosophy, so he treated philosophy as the supplier of the church's errors. Yet he was trained in rhetoric and Stoic thought, and he coined the Latin vocabulary of trinitas, substantia and persona. The line credo quia absurdum is a later paraphrase and appears nowhere in his works.

Key idea Tertullian marks a boundary, not an exit: the church may use the world's tools but not accept its questions.
At a glance

Two ways to meet a culture

Justin's road

Enter and transform what is true in the culture. The risk is a gospel that dissolves into the culture it entered.

Tertullian's road

Hold a boundary against the world's questions. The risk is a church that is a foreign enclave for generations.

Neither is a compromise

There is no third option that avoids both risks. Tertullian, who drew the hardest line, later joined the New Prophecy movement outside the church.

Outcome

Failure, and an unintended success

There is no evidence that any emperor read an apology or that one stopped a persecution. But the apologies gave the church a habit of public argument, a working vocabulary in Greek and Latin, and a conviction that the faith could be stated to someone who did not already hold it. Without that vocabulary, the councils of chapter 5 could not have met.

Key idea Their most durable legacy is the disagreement itself.
Think about it

The Justin and Tertullian decision

Every congregation in a religiously plural place makes this decision constantly, for example over funeral customs that include rites for the ancestors, or a national festival with religious roots.

In a setting you know, which of these would you treat as a contact point to enter, and which as a boundary to hold?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Justin said philosophy held seeds of the Word and Tertullian said philosophy supplied the church's errors. Both refused to let their enemies describe the faith, and neither trimmed the offensive part. A community is defined by what it will not do, and these men would not let the account of who they were be written by anyone else.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12