FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind

Martyrdom left the church commemorations, martyr acts and a theology of suffering. Its hardest inheritance was what to do with the lapsed, and the church chose to be a body that could take people back.

Early Church History

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain the theological basis on which martyrdom was understood as participation in Christ's victory rather than as defeat, and state the limits the church itself placed on that.
  • State what the claim "the blood of the martyrs is seed" meant to the man who wrote it, and assess honestly what it does and does not establish.
  • Describe what martyrdom left to the church — the commemorations, the martyr acts, and a theology of suffering — and explain the crisis of the lapsed.
  • State the question this material puts to a church that is comfortable, without turning it into either flattery or accusation.
Polycarp

The people closest to it were not romantic

Around 155 the church of Smyrna wrote an account of the death of its bishop, Polycarp. He did not hand himself in, but withdrew to a farm and was arrested only when a servant was tortured. He refused every way out the proconsul offered. The same letter records Quintus, who volunteered, urged others to do the same, and then sacrificed at the sight of the beasts. It states that the gospel does not teach giving yourself up.

Key idea The sources praise Polycarp and criticise Quintus in the same letter.
Scripture

Why 2 Corinthians 4:8–9?

The lecture points out that in each pair the second half is smaller than you expect. Paul concedes the whole of the pressure and denies only the final word, which the lecture calls its entire theology.

We are pressed on every side, yet not crushed; perplexed, yet not to despair; pursued, yet not forsaken; struck down, yet not destroyed." 2 Corinthians 4:8–9 · World English Bible
The word

Martys means witness

Martys is an ordinary Greek word for a witness who testifies in court about what they saw. When testifying to Christ became the thing that got you killed, the word for the testimony came to mean the death. A martyr is not primarily someone who dies, but someone who says something under conditions in which saying it is fatal.

Key idea The dying is the circumstance, and the testimony is the act.
At a glance

Why it was not defeat, and the limits

Union with Christ

Martyrdom was seen as the sharpest form of dying and rising with Christ. Ignatius begged the Roman church not to save him.

Hope and public testimony

If death is not the end, the state's ultimate sanction is not ultimate. Executions staged as spectacle gave the church a platform it had not asked for.

The limits

Volunteering was discouraged and flight was legitimate. Cyprian hid because a bishop is more useful to his people alive. A Christian may not buy life with a lie.

The seed

"The blood of Christians is seed"

The line is Tertullian's, a taunt at the end of a defence speech, not a demographic finding. The composure of the condemned made a real impression, and Justin says it was part of what converted him. As a general explanation of growth it is contested: Rodney Stark pointed to steady growth through family and friendship, and Candida Moss argued the scale of persecution was exaggerated. Her claim is disputed sharply.

Key idea That persecution grew the church is a claim, not something the evidence establishes.
Inheritance

What it left behind

Martyrdom left three things. The commemorations gathered at martyrs' graves on their birthday and grew into the church's year of saints, and the traditions divide over where that led. The martyr acts, such as the Acts of Justin and the Passion of Perpetua, were the church's first literature about itself after the New Testament. And a conviction that suffering for Christ is not a sign of God's absence, which has both consoled people in extremity and been misused.

Key idea The acts should be read critically, and they should be read.
The lapsed

Three answers after Decius

The rigorists

No forgiveness after denial. Novatian in Rome held this and became a rival bishop. The position takes the martyrs seriously: if a certificate costs nothing, what did those who refused die for?

The lax

Immediate restoration, with confessors issuing pardons on their own authority.

Cyprian's middle way

Restoration through public penance graded by what each person did, and administered by the bishop. It took time and was humiliating, and at the end you were back.

Think about it

Your libellus

Nearly every Christian is at some point asked for the small formality, the signature or the silence that costs nothing and would keep a business open or a family unembarrassed.

What is the small, cheap thing that you have been asked to sign or attend, and how did you answer?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A martyr is a witness, and the church taught that martyrdom may be accepted but not arranged. Its hardest decision was to take back people who had failed, so the church became a body for people who had failed, not a society of the proven. Having found its edge, it decided not to make that edge the condition of belonging.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12