Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
The church defined its faith about matter, a real body and an open door because teachers of secret knowledge forced it to.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
The church defined its faith about matter, a real body and an open door because teachers of secret knowledge forced it to.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
In December 1945 men digging near Nag Hammadi in Egypt found thirteen codices in Coptic, around fifty texts. Until then almost everything known about these teachers came from the people who wrote against them. The texts confirmed much of what Irenaeus reported, but they also showed far more variety than the ancient summaries suggest. So the lecture uses "Gnosticism" as a label for a family resemblance, not for a church.
Gnosis is Greek for knowledge, closer to recognition than to learning. On this account the human spirit is a fragment of the divine that has forgotten where it came from, and salvation is waking up. So there is no debt, no reconciliation and no forgiveness to speak of. Several systems also sorted people into kinds by nature, and for some there was nothing to save.
The underlying dualism held spirit to be good and matter evil. A good God cannot have made evil, so the world was made by a lesser craftsman, the demiurge, who is ignorant of the true God or hostile to him. The move that made this a Christian problem was identifying him with the God of the Old Testament. That is why the creed's first article says maker of heaven and earth.
The lecture rests on the verb in this verse: the Word became flesh, not appeared as or entered into flesh. It uses the verse to ask whether that sentence is meant literally.
The Word became flesh, and lived among us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the one and only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." John 1:14 · World English Bible
From the Greek for "to seem" comes docetism, the claim that Christ only appeared to have a body. If so, the atonement goes, because a phantom cannot die for anyone. The resurrection goes with it, since there was no body to raise. The incarnation is emptied, and your own flesh cannot be saved.
Salvation by knowing what you really are. Matter is evil. The world was made by a lesser craftsman. Christ only seemed to have a body. Truth is passed privately to initiates.
Grace received by faith. Creation is very good. One God is both maker and redeemer. The Word became flesh. The tradition is public, and the church is open to anybody.
Irenaeus, writing around 180, replied that creation is good and its maker is the Father of Jesus Christ. He argued that the tradition is public: the churches the apostles founded can be visited, and they teach the same thing. And he held that the church is for anybody, which is the sense of the word catholic. Out of the first point he built recapitulation, Christ going back over human life and getting it right.
The lecture says the instinct underneath these teachings has not gone away. It shows up wherever the spiritual is treated as the real thing and the physical as scenery.
What does your church's practice imply about the value of bodies, and what in its teaching could a visitor check for themselves?
The church did not define its faith until someone forced it to. Against teachers of saving knowledge it said that the world is good, that the Word truly became flesh, and that the door is open to anyone. These became the first article of every creed since.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.