FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy

One man cut Scripture down and a movement added to it. The church's answers to both shaped the canon, the creed and the office.

Early Church History

12 cards 23 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain Marcion's two gods and his edited scripture, and state clearly what is wrong with each.
  • Describe the task Marcion's challenge set the church over the canon, and say honestly how much of the church's canon he can be credited with prompting.
  • Explain what the New Prophecy claimed, where it collided with the church's order, and what the church was actually objecting to — which is not what it is usually said to be.
  • Explain how canon, creed and episcopal office were each reinforced by one of these two crises.
Marcion

Two gods and a shorter Bible

Marcion read the Old Testament and Paul and concluded they could not describe the same God. The Creator of the Jewish scriptures is just but severe, while above him is the Stranger, a God of pure love who owes nobody anything. Marcion discarded the Old Testament and kept an edited Luke and ten letters of Paul. The lecture asks that his case be stated at its strongest, as pure gratuity.

Key idea A God who owes you nothing and came to get you anyway.
Three faults

What the church named

The church named three faults. It makes the Christian God an accident, because the world and the human race are then someone else's property. It cannot make sense of Jesus, who quoted the Jewish scriptures as authoritative. And it has no external check, since Marcion decided what belonged in the Bible by whether it agreed with his theology.

Key idea The test for Scripture was his own theology, a closed circle.
The canon

Which books, and why?

Marcion forced a question the church had left open: which books, and why? Scholars disagree how far he created the New Testament, since the four gospels and Paul's letters were already being collected. The church's most consequential decision was to keep the Old Testament, though dropping it would have been easier. In doing so it committed itself to the God who made the world and chose Israel being the Father of Jesus Christ.

Key idea The church kept the Old Testament.
The New Prophecy

The Spirit, still speaking

Around the 170s Montanus, with Priscilla and Maximilla, prophesied in Phrygia in the first person as the voice of the Spirit. They announced that the end was near and asked for strict rigour. Their doctrine was orthodox. The objections were to the manner of the prophecy, the claim that God was still issuing binding instructions, the rigour, and authority that could not be corrected.

Key idea The issue was not doctrine but whether what was handed down is enough.
Scripture

Why 1 John 4:1?

The lecture uses this verse because it says to test the spirits, neither silencing them nor believing them. That assumes something stable to test against, which is what the chapter is about.

Beloved, don't believe every spirit, but test the spirits, whether they are of God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world." 1 John 4:1 · World English Bible
At a glance

Too little and too much

Marcion: too little

The Creator and the Father of Jesus are two gods. He cut Scripture down. The church answered with a canon and kept the Old Testament.

The New Prophecy: too much

The Spirit is speaking now, through named prophets. They added continuing revelation. The church answered with the sufficiency of what was handed down and the accountability of teaching.

Cost

What the church knew it was losing

Prophecy appears warmly in the New Testament, and Paul tells the Corinthians to desire it. In closing the question of new revelation the church accepted a real cost. Tertullian, the great Latin defender of the rule of faith, ended his life in the New Prophecy. The line between defending the faith and demanding more than the church can bear is not visible from inside.

Key idea Tertullian is this chapter's best warning.
Think about it

Two drifts

The lecture names two modern drifts. One is a church that has quietly abandoned most of its Bible. The other is a leader's private word from God that nothing can check.

Over the last three years, how much of the preaching you have heard came from the Old Testament, and what would a prophetic claim in your congregation be tested against?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Marcion forced the canon, and the New Prophecy forced the question of sufficiency and a rule of faith. Both forced the office, because the church pointed to public, continuous teaching against a lone teacher or a private spirit. The church had assumed that the God of Israel is the Father of Jesus and that what the apostles handed on was enough, and only now said so.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12