Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
Two handshakes link the resurrection to the first systematic theology. The people in between were holding a church together and handing it on.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Two handshakes link the resurrection to the first systematic theology. The people in between were holding a church together and handing it on.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Irenaeus, writing in Gaul around 180, remembered hearing the old bishop Polycarp as a boy. Polycarp used to describe his conversations with John and with others who had seen the Lord. That is the whole distance from the resurrection to the first systematic theology of the church. Irenaeus tells it as an argument, though it is also simply what the transmission looked like.
"Apostolic Fathers" is not an ancient title. It is a seventeenth-century editorial category for the earliest Christian writings outside the New Testament. The authors were not building a system. They were trying to keep churches from falling apart, such as a congregation in Corinth that had thrown out its elders.
The lecture uses this verse because it has four links in one sentence: Paul, Timothy, faithful people, others. Its phrase "among many witnesses" says the handing on is not private.
The things which you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit the same to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also." 2 Timothy 2:2 · World English Bible
Clement wrote to Corinth around 96 about order and humility. Ignatius, on his way to die around 110, pleaded for one assembly in each city and for the reality of Christ's flesh.
Polycarp disagreed with Rome about the date of Easter, yet they stayed in communion. The Didache is a manual on baptism, the meal, fasting and travelling teachers.
The apologists wrote for an audience outside the church, who granted none of its claims. Justin argued that philosophy had a partial share of the truth, a seed of the Word in everyone who reasons. Tertullian held the opposite instinct while building the Latin vocabulary the councils would need. They left the church a technical language and a licence to argue in it.
Irenaeus tied Scripture to the rule of faith, using the image of a mosaic of a king rearranged into a dog. He made the tradition public, so that it could be checked. He also gave the answer a positive form in recapitulation: Christ passing back over human life and getting it right, so that creation is healed. The lecture notes that his chain from John through Polycarp is probably true in substance, and also an interested party's argument.
This generation understood itself as handing on rather than producing. Yet they innovated constantly, while insisting they were stating what they had received. Their test was not "is this new?" but "does this fit the shape of what we were given?" The lecture also says this was not a golden age: Corinth had thrown out its elders and congregations were splitting.
Polycarp and the bishop of Rome disagreed about Easter and remained in communion.
What is your congregation currently treating as church-dividing that an earlier generation would not have?
At the start of the chapter the church had letters, memories, congregations and habits. At the end it had a canon taking shape, a rule of faith, an office, a theological vocabulary and a systematic account of what it believed. None of it was planned, and it was made by people who thought they were repeating what they had heard.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.