Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
Emperors held great power over the church's institutions and much less over its faith. Resistance needed somewhere to stand.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Emperors held great power over the church's institutions and much less over its faith. Resistance needed somewhere to stand.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
In 390 Theodosius ordered a reprisal after a riot in Thessalonica, and the reported death toll is seven thousand. Ambrose of Milan wrote to him as an ally, saying that he loved him and could not offer the eucharist in his presence until he had done public penance. Theodosius did the penance, standing among the penitents without his imperial robes. This is the counterweight to a story of a church simply absorbed by a state.
The lecture uses this verse because it first served for a church with no power refusing an order. Here it returns for a church with a great deal of power, where the question changes shape because the ruler is a believer who funds its work.
But Peter and the apostles answered, 'We must obey God rather than men.'" Acts 5:29 · World English Bible
Eusebius taught that one God in heaven is mirrored by one emperor on earth, who rules as God's image and friend. The lecture does not fault him for being positive about the state, since Romans 13 is too. The failure is that it removes the possibility of criticism, with no place for Nathan telling David "you are the man". It also built a theology out of a single generation's arrangement, and a theology that depends on the empire lasting cannot survive the empire.
Justinian's legislation says God gave humanity two gifts, the priesthood and the imperial dignity, which together produce harmony. It assigns two spheres, each answerable to God rather than to the other. Its practical weakness is that it contains no mechanism for disagreement. The emperor had the army, the treasury and the right of appointment, so in practice the relationship was asymmetrical far more often than harmonious.
They summoned councils, appointed and removed bishops such as Chrysostom, and from 380 enforced orthodoxy by law. In 385 Priscillian was the first Christian executed by a Christian state for heresy.
Emperors backed Arianism for decades and lost. Monothelitism was condemned. Iconoclasm was imposed twice and reversed twice. Reunions with Rome were repudiated by clergy and people.
"Caesaropapism" is a modern Western coinage that Byzantine specialists mostly dislike, and Gilbert Dagron's study is the standard statement of why. The objection is empirical, because the label implies emperors could decide what the church believed. They could exile a bishop, close a church and appoint a patriarch. What they repeatedly could not do was make the church believe something.
Athanasius was exiled five times and outlasted every emperor, with the loyalty of Egypt and the desert behind him. Ambrose had the sacraments and a believing emperor. John of Damascus wrote against iconoclasm from Palestine, under Muslim rule, outside the empire's reach. The monks had nothing to lose, and the church that had none of these places to stand was the one that was absorbed.
Each successful resister had somewhere the emperor could not reach.
Where would your congregation's leaders stand if refusing cost them their position, their funding or their legal status?
Eusebius's theology could not criticise an emperor, and the church acquired the habit of settling arguments by exile. In the same period it held councils that produced the creed most Christians still recite, defied emperors, and made one do public penance for a massacre. Freedom cost the church things persecution never could, and bought it things persecution never could.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.