Lecture 8-3: The Franks and the Popes — an Alliance and Its Price
The Frankish kings and the popes each had something the other needed, and the alliance brought gains and debts together.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
The Frankish kings and the popes each had something the other needed, and the alliance brought gains and debts together.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
On Christmas Day 800 Pope Leo III crowned the Frankish king Charles emperor. Eighteen months earlier Leo had been attacked by a faction of the Roman aristocracy, escaped, and asked the Frankish king for help. Charles sent him back with an escort, presided over the hearing at which Leo cleared himself, and was crowned two days later. The lecture says this course ends about 600, so everything after its first section is outside it and given as the shape of the road.
Clovis was baptised a Catholic at Reims. Every other major Germanic kingdom was Homoian, so he went from Frankish religion directly to the faith of the Gallo-Roman population. That gave him the bishops and landowners of Gaul as allies. The date is uncertain, the story comes from Gregory of Tours ninety years later, and nobody can see his motives, though the consequences were political and enormous.
Pepin asked Pope Zachary whether the man with the power should hold the title of king, and in 751 he was made king and anointed with oil. In 754 Pope Stephen II anointed him again. Pepin then defeated the Lombards and gave the recovered land to the pope, the Donation of Pepin that began the Papal States. The lecture says legitimacy conferred by the church is a power the church can be asked to withdraw.
The lecture notes Paul wrote this about a pagan government, and that in this period it is read as a text about Christian rulers and whoever crowns them. It says to watch how much weight is put on a verse that is not about coronations.
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God." Romans 13:1 · World English Bible
The coronation filled a legal gap, since the imperial title belonged to Constantinople, where Irene then reigned. It did not create the Holy Roman Empire, a later name. Constantinople recognised Charles as basileus only in 812, and the continuous institution is usually dated from Otto I in 962. In 813 Charles crowned his son Louis himself at Aachen, with no pope present.
A public order in which political power admits it is answerable to something above itself, and a papacy able to hold rulers to a standard. Abuse does not make the principle wrong.
The West took the road the East refused, replacing symphonia with a bishop who makes and unmakes emperors and is himself a temporal sovereign.
The sequence fused Christ's kingdom with an empire. Protestants add that the Reformation states built their own established churches within a generation.
Charlemagne gathered scholars such as Alcuin, ordered cathedrals and monasteries to run schools, and had a corrected Vulgate prepared. Caroline minuscule is the reason a very large part of classical Latin literature survives. In the same reign the capitulary for conquered Saxony prescribed death for refusing baptism. Alcuin wrote that faith arises from the will and cannot be compelled, and the criticism existed and was correct, but it did not stop anything.
In three centuries the Western church gained a Catholic monarchy, a sovereign territory, the power to confer a crown, a standard liturgy, schools and manuscripts. It also gained an army it depended on, estates to defend and claims neither side could enforce. The work of the state came with the debts of the state.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.