FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-4: Christendom — a Society Entirely Inside the Church

In Christendom the whole of society sat inside the church, which brought real gains and the debts the church had inherited.

Early Church History

11 cards 26 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what "Christendom" names — a society coextensive with the church — and describe both the unity it supplied to a politically fragmented Europe and the assumption it built in.
  • Set out the scheme of those who pray, those who fight and those who work, explain the theological reasoning that justified it, date it accurately, and say what it concealed.
  • Describe the church's double position as landholder and as tenant of kings, and explain how that produced the conflict over the appointment of bishops.
  • Explain Gelasius's two powers and the later doctrine of the two swords, distinguish them, and describe the relationship between sacral kingship and papal claims that they were used to argue about.
  • Assess what Christendom achieved and what it cost, stating the Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant verdicts fairly, and identify where the church's own reformers made the criticism first.
Beyond the boundary

Where the course looks ahead

Around 1025 Bishop Adalbero of Laon wrote that the house of God is threefold: some pray, some fight, and some work. The poem is a complaint that the order was breaking down. The lecture says it is the one place the course looks past its own boundary on purpose, because the ninth to twelfth centuries belong to CH102.

Key idea Read this lecture as the shape of the road.
Christendom

A situation, not a government

From roughly the ninth century to the sixteenth, everyone in western Europe was baptised and one church held the same faith across every political boundary. Political Europe shattered and ecclesiastical Europe did not, and that asymmetry is what Christendom is. The gains included a common law of marriage, a common language of learning, canon law that applied to kings, hospitals and sanctuary. The assumption was that being a member of society and of the church were the same act, with no outside.

Key idea The church became the frame of society.
Three orders

Pray, fight, work

The scheme divides society into oratores, bellatores and laboratores. Each order is under obligation to the others, and the Peace and Truce of God movements used that to limit private warfare. The lecture, following Georges Duby, treats the scheme as a weapon in an argument about how society ought to work. It had no place for townsmen and presented a hierarchy of birth as the shape of God's will, so it should be read with the question of who benefits in view.

Key idea A providential social position is hard to call unjust.
Scripture

Why John 18:36?

The lecture calls this the standing objection to everything in the lecture. It says the verse tells where Christ's kingdom comes from, not where it applies, and the question is what happens when a church becomes indistinguishable from the public order.

Jesus answered, 'My Kingdom is not of this world. If my Kingdom were of this world, then my servants would fight, that I wouldn't be delivered to the Jews. But now my Kingdom is not from here.'" John 18:36 · World English Bible
Landlord and tenant

Why kings appointed bishops

A bishop or abbot held estates that carried jurisdiction, revenues and the duty to supply armed men to a king. So a bishop was both a spiritual officer and a secular officeholder, and no king could let someone else appoint him. Lords also owned the churches built on their land, and church posts were bought and sold. The church inherited the work of the state in the sixth century, and by the tenth the state's successors owned the church.

Key idea The conflict over appointments was structural.
At a glance

Two powers, two swords

Two powers

Gelasius I wrote in 494 of the consecrated authority of bishops and the royal power. Bishops obey the emperor in public order, and the emperor submits to bishops in religion. It distinguishes two spheres without subordinating either.

Two swords

From the ninth century Luke 22 was read as the spiritual and temporal power, both belonging to the church, with the second entrusted to the ruler to be drawn at the church's direction. Boniface VIII put this in a bull in 1302. Do not read it back into Gelasius.

Think about it

A defensible step at a time

The bishops who fed cities when the grain ships stopped were right to feed them, and Gregory was right to buy back captives.

Where does a church you know carry responsibilities it could not refuse without abandoning people, and how has carrying them changed it?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Christendom was a society entirely inside the church, produced by the sixth-century inheritance of the work of the state. It gave Europe a shared law, learning and care for the poor, and it carried the debts of landholding, kings' control of bishops and the treatment of those outside. It is not a story of a church seduced by power but of one handed responsibilities it could not refuse. The course asks you to state each tradition's verdict fairly and does not ask you to reach one.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11