FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH102E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-2: Iconoclasm — Images, Empire and the Incarnation

The icon controversy was a fight about the incarnation and about imperial power. It ended in agreement on doctrine but left East and West further apart.

Medieval Church History

13 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain the historical background to Leo III's edict against images and the mixture of religious and political motives behind it.
  • State the theological issue between iconoclasts and iconodules as a question about the incarnation, not about decoration.
  • Explain how John of Damascus defended icons by distinguishing latreia from proskynesis, and why he was safe enough to write it.
  • Describe how the quarrel became a contest between imperial power and the independence of the monasteries and the papacy, and how the Second Council of Nicaea settled it.
The problem

A serious case against images

The second commandment forbids making a carved image and bowing down to it. By the seventh century the Byzantine world was full of icons. The iconoclast case was not philistine. It was biblical and serious. If veneration is not carefully distinguished from worship, a church commanded to worship God alone has quietly begun doing something else.

Key idea The worry about popular religion drifting was not imaginary.
The edict

Leo III and an empire looking for its sin

In 717 an Arab army and fleet besieged Constantinople, and the city survived barely. Leo III is traditionally said to have moved against images in stages from around 726, asking why God was allowing the empire to be dismembered. But almost everything we know about the first phase comes from later sources written by its opponents. Brubaker and Haldon argue the early measures were far smaller than the traditional account says.

Key idea The controversy is real, but the tidy account of its beginning is not secure.
The argument

Incarnation and representation

Under Constantine V the iconoclast case became theological. Christ is one person in two natures. To paint him, you paint either the divine nature, which is impossible, or the human nature only, which separates the natures. So any icon of Christ is heretical, said the Council of Hieria in 754. John of Damascus replied that an icon depicts a person, and this person truly took a body that could be seen, touched and drawn.

Key idea Both sides were defending Chalcedon, and each thought the other had left it.
Scripture

Why Colossians 1:15?

The lecture's summary table lists this verse among the Scripture the iconodules leaned on, beside the incarnation itself.

He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation." Colossians 1:15 · World English Bible
At a glance

Two kinds of bowing

Latreia

Worship, adoration, the total self-giving owed to God alone. To offer it to a creature is idolatry.

Proskynesis

Reverence, honour, the bow. Scripture shows it offered to people and places. Icons receive this, never latreia.

Emperor and church

Who governs the church?

Constantine V closed monasteries and took their lands. The struggle became about whether an emperor may define doctrine. Popes Gregory II and Gregory III rejected the imperial policy. Illyricum, southern Italy and Sicily were then detached from Rome and placed under Constantinople. Deprived of imperial protection, the papacy turned toward the Franks.

Key idea Some scholars date the transfer later, but the loss to Rome is certain.
Nicaea II

A translation that made things worse

In 787 the Second Council of Nicaea restored the icons. It allowed honourable veneration, but not the true latreia that belongs to God alone. The controversy ended for good in 843. In the West, the acts reached Charlemagne's court in a Latin translation that rendered both Greek words with forms of adoratio. The Franks replied with the Libri Carolini, rejecting a council they had not actually read.

Key idea The one distinction the council turned on was translated away.
The cost

Agreement, but a wider gap

East and West both venerate images and both deny them worship, so there is no doctrinal schism here. What was left behind was structural. Rome had lost jurisdictions it never recovered and had begun looking to the Franks. The Franks had formed their first strong opinion about Eastern theology from a mistranslation. Both sides were, in the end, right about the same thing.

Key idea The damage was real even though the doctrine agreed.
Think about it

Where might a word decide?

Latreia and proskynesis were collapsed into one Latin word, and a council was rejected because of it.

Where might a translation be quietly deciding a question in your own tradition?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The question was whether Christ, who took a visible body, may be painted. John of Damascus separated worship, owed to God alone, from honour, which passes to the one an image represents. The doctrine ended in agreement, but a mistranslation and a century of imperial policy left East and West further apart.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13