FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH102E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent

The excommunications of 1054 gave the division a date. What made it permanent came after: the sack of Constantinople in 1204 and unions that the church rejected.

Medieval Church History

13 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain how the geopolitics of southern Italy and the reforming papacy of the eleventh century set up the collision.
  • Describe how Humbert and Cerularius turned a dispute into mutual excommunication in Hagia Sophia.
  • Explain why the Fourth Crusade of 1204 and the failed reunions at Lyons and Florence made the schism permanent.
  • State the lasting consequences of the division, and the meaning of the mutual lifting of the anathemas in 1965.
The setting

Southern Italy, where two churches touched

Southern Italy had been moved from Roman to Constantinopolitan jurisdiction under Leo III. By the 1040s Normans were conquering Greek-rite territory and installing Latin bishops, who required Latin practice. Patriarch Michael Cerularius answered by closing the Latin-rite churches in Constantinople. Each side believed the other's practice was wrong, and practice had become a flag.

Key idea Neither side was inventing a theological quarrel to justify a political one.
Rome in the 1050s

A reforming papacy

The Cluniac reform movement wanted the church free from lay control. By the time of Pope Leo IX, the reform party held Rome and wanted a church governed from Rome. Reform and centralisation arrived together. Cardinal Humbert was its sharpest voice, and Cerularius was a patriarch of comparable stubbornness. The emperor wanted agreement, but the personalities did not.

Key idea The politics pointed toward agreement. The personalities did not.
16 July 1054

A bull on the altar

Pope Leo IX died on 19 April 1054, and the talks had already failed. On 16 July, Humbert and the other legates laid a bull of excommunication on the high altar of Hagia Sophia. It named Cerularius and his followers, not the Eastern church as such. Its charges mixed the serious, the trivial and the untrue. Cerularius anathematised the legates in return.

Key idea Two limited excommunications became the conventional date of a schism only in retrospect.
1204

The wound for the East

The Fourth Crusade was diverted to Constantinople, and in April 1204 it took the city and sacked it for three days. Churches were stripped, relics were carried off, and a Latin emperor and patriarch were installed. Pope Innocent III had not ordered the attack and condemned it. For the Eastern church, the wound is 1204 more than 1054.

Key idea After 1204, reunion became a problem of memory.
At a glance

Two reunions that were rejected

Lyons, 1274

The emperor Michael VIII needed Western help and accepted union on Roman terms. His clergy and people rejected it, and the union collapsed with him.

Florence, 1439

With the Ottomans at the walls, the Byzantine delegation signed a decree of union. Mark of Ephesus refused to sign, and the union was repudiated in Constantinople soon after.

The pattern

A treaty is not communion

Both unions were negotiated by rulers and hierarchs under military pressure. Both were rejected by the body of the church. Union imposed from the top in exchange for troops is a treaty, not communion. In 1453 Constantinople fell to the Ottomans.

Key idea The faithful knew the difference.
1965

A gesture, not a reunion

On 7 December 1965, Pope Paul VI and the Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras issued a joint declaration. It removed the mutual excommunications from the memory of the church. It did not restore communion, and the churches do not share the Eucharist. It ended the claim that a valid sentence of condemnation keeps them apart.

Key idea What remains is nine hundred years of divergence, and 1204.
Scripture

Why Psalm 133:1?

The lecture sets this verse over the whole story. It says the psalm is about a household, and nothing in this lecture is about a household.

See how good and how pleasant it is for brothers to live together in unity!" Psalm 133:1 · World English Bible
Think about it

Agreement the body can receive

The lecture says union imposed from the top under pressure is not communion.

What would it take for an agreement in your church to be one that the whole body can receive?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

1054 gave the division a date, but 1204 gave it a memory. Reunions signed under pressure were rejected by the church. The lecture concludes that doctrine is rarely what breaks a church. It is what people are willing to do to each other while defending it.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13