FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH102E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-4: Francis and Dominic

Francis and Dominic founded orders that owned nothing and lived in the cities. This lecture asks what was new about them and what it cost.

Medieval Church History

14 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why the growth of cities and a money economy made the older monastic pattern inadequate, and what the mendicant orders offered instead.
  • Describe Francis's ideal of Lady Poverty and the meaning of minores.
  • Describe Dominic's pursuit of veritas and why his order made study a form of poverty.
  • Assess what the mendicant orders changed in the church's approach to mission, and what they cost.
The scene

Damietta, 1219

While a crusading army besieged the city of Damietta, Francis of Assisi walked out of the Christian camp and asked to see the Sultan. The Sultan listened, declined to convert, and sent him back unharmed. Nothing came of it politically. In the same decade the same church was besieging that city and producing that man.

Key idea The church of that decade held both an army and a man who walked out to talk.
Scripture

Why Matthew 8:20?

The lecture says Francis took this verse as a description of a way of life rather than a remark about circumstances. It says the whole Franciscan argument is contained in that decision.

Jesus said to him, 'The foxes have holes and the birds of the sky have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.'" Matthew 8:20 · World English Bible
Background

Why the old model no longer fitted

Benedictine monasticism was a rural institution, and a monk joined one house and stayed in it. By 1200 the people had moved to growing cities, and the monasteries had become landlords. A mendicant order answered both problems. It owns no property at all, and its members live in cities on alms and daily work.

Key idea Friars are not monks. They move where they are needed.
Francis

Lady Poverty and the lesser ones

Francis spoke of poverty as a bride, which he called Lady Poverty. It was not a discipline he was undergoing. It was a person he loved, and marrying her was joy rather than deprivation. He named his followers the Friars Minor, the lesser brothers. In Italian towns the minores were the small people, so he chose the wrong end of a class label.

Key idea Francis chose poverty as a joy and chose to be among the small.
Francis

Mission by presence

The Franciscan Rule of 1221 has a chapter on going among the Saracens, the first instruction of its kind in Western Christianity. Some friars may simply live among them peaceably, confessing themselves Christians. Others may preach when they see it pleases God. This is a mission that begins with presence rather than conquest, and it allows silence as a form of witness.

Key idea The church's answer in 1219 was an army. Francis's answer was to walk over and talk.
Dominic

Truth, and men who could answer

Dominic met the Cathar perfecti, who were visibly holy, and papal legates who arrived with horses and servants. He concluded that you answer opponents who are poor and persuasive with people who are poorer and more persuasive. His Order of Preachers, approved in 1216, took the motto veritas, which means truth. Dominican poverty extended to time, so that friars were freed to study.

Key idea A preacher who cannot answer a hard question is no use.
At a glance

Franciscans and Dominicans

Franciscans

Founder Francis. Watchword: Lady Poverty and the minores. Poverty is joyful. Great legacy: Damietta and a mission without an army.

Dominicans

Founder Dominic. Watchword: veritas. Poverty frees time to study. Great legacy: Albert the Great and Thomas Aquinas.

What changed

What the mendicants changed

The orders brought mobility instead of stability, and the city instead of the countryside. Preaching and confession became the core work, and study became a vocation. Both orders also developed third orders for lay people living ordinary lives under a rule. Readers disagree whether this renewed the church from inside or domesticated a dangerous movement.

Key idea The lecture says the evidence supports both readings.
The cost

What happened to the ideal

Francis wanted absolute poverty, and an order of thousands cannot easily have none. The papacy held the title to Franciscan property and the friars merely used it. A faction called the Spirituals rejected this, and some were burned as heretics in the 1310s and 1320s. The Dominicans, formed to out-argue dissenters, came to staff the Inquisition from the 1230s.

Key idea Both orders were built for persuasion and turned to coercion within a generation.
Think about it

Two facts about one church

In 1219 the church was besieging Damietta and Francis was walking into it to talk.

Both were the church. How do you hold those two facts together without excusing either?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The same energy produced armed crusade and poor preaching. Francis walked out of a besieging army to talk, and the mendicants answered the lay hunger of the age. Both orders were soon turned to coercion or fought over.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 14