FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH102E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-4: The University

The university was a medieval invention. This lecture covers where it came from, how it taught, and what it could not do.

Medieval Church History

14 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Trace the development from monastic school through cathedral school to universitas, and explain what kind of body a universitas actually was.
  • Name the seven liberal arts in their two groups and explain their place in the path to theology.
  • Explain lectio and disputatio and what each was for.
  • Assess the historical consequences of the university, including its limits.
The invention

The institution you may have lived in

The lecture, the reading list, the examination, the degree, the faculty and the doctoral defence were all invented between about 1150 and 1250. This mostly happened in Bologna, Paris and Oxford. Most of it still works the way it was designed to work. The lecture also asks why this engine for producing trained minds did not save the church from what happens in chapter 4.

Key idea The medieval invention you are most likely to have lived inside is the university.
Scripture

Why 2 Timothy 2:15?

The lecture says the medieval university took the words a workman who doesn't need to be ashamed as a job description. It says the university built a fifteen-year training programme to produce one.

Give diligence to present yourself approved by God, a workman who doesn't need to be ashamed, properly handling the Word of Truth." 2 Timothy 2:15 · WEB
Origins

What a universitas actually was

A universitas was not a place or a set of buildings. The word is ordinary Latin for a corporation, a legally recognised guild. A universitas of masters and scholars was formed to bargain collectively with a town and a bishop. A guild can go on strike, and in 1229 the masters of Paris suspended teaching and dispersed for two years.

Key idea The word for the teaching enterprise was studium generale.
At a glance

Bologna and Paris

Bologna

A students' guild. Students hired the professors and paid their salaries, so they set the terms.

Paris

A masters' guild. The masters controlled admission to their own body, which meant they controlled the licence to teach. It became the model for northern Europe, including Oxford and Cambridge.

The degree

A bachelor was an apprentice

The licentia docendi, the licence to teach, was a guild qualification. A bachelor was an apprentice, and a master was a qualified practitioner. The ceremony of graduation was a guild's admission of a new member. The lecture says that is still, formally, what a graduation is.

Key idea The degree began as a guild certificate.
The curriculum

Seven liberal arts, then theology

The undergraduate curriculum was the seven liberal arts. The trivium was grammar, rhetoric and logic, the arts of words. The quadrivium was arithmetic, geometry, astronomy and music, the arts of number. Then came law, medicine and theology, and theology was the longest road, commonly fifteen years or more.

Key idea The study of God is not a beginner's subject, and enthusiasm is not a qualification.
Scripture

Why Proverbs 4:7?

The lecture lists this verse as one of its two Scripture passages, beside 2 Timothy 2:15, for a school system built around getting wisdom and understanding.

Wisdom is supreme. Get wisdom. Yes, though it costs all your possessions, get understanding." Proverbs 4:7 · World English Bible
Teaching

Lectio and disputatio

In the lectio, a master read an authoritative text aloud and commented on it phrase by phrase. Books were expensive manuscripts, so the lecture was the book. In the disputatio, a bachelor defended a position, opponents attacked it, and the master gave a final resolution. It was public and oral, and it was the real examination.

Key idea The disputation was the difference between receiving a tradition and testing it.
Teaching

The Summa is the transcript of a room

The Summa's pattern of objections, counter-authority, answer and replies is the form of a disputation written down. Your opponent was present, so you could not caricature a position when its holder stood in the hall waiting to reply. The lecture says the courtesy was structural rather than moral. A doctoral defence today is a medieval disputation with the Latin removed.

Key idea Opposing views are stated well because the opponent was in the room.
Limits

What the university could not do

The university gave Europe a common language, Latin, and a place where new learning could be examined. Universities held charters from popes and kings and answered fully to neither. Women were excluded entirely. Paris in 1300 did not prevent Avignon or the Great Western Schism, because the crisis was one of money, power, patronage and nerve.

Key idea An institution that produces excellent answers is not thereby an institution that can act.
One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The medieval church built the university, and we still use it. It deserves admiration, and it also had limits. Faith seeking understanding builds cathedrals of thought, and cannot by itself keep a church honest.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 14