FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH102E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes

For thirty-nine years no one in Europe could know who the pope was. This lecture follows how the papacy got there.

Medieval Church History

14 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain the significance of the collision between Boniface VIII and Philip IV, and why Unam Sanctam and Anagni belong in the same paragraph.
  • Describe the Avignon papacy and explain how its French character and its financial system damaged its spiritual authority.
  • Narrate how the Great Western Schism began in 1378 and why the Council of Pisa in 1409 made it worse.
  • Assess what the schism did to ordinary belief and to the standing of the papal office.
The problem

No way to know who the pope was

From 1378 to 1417 an ordinary European Christian had no way to know who the pope was. Two men, and after 1409 three, each held a valid-looking election and each excommunicated the others and their followers. So every Christian in Europe was excommunicated by somebody. No available authority could settle which excommunication counted.

Key idea The lecture follows how this happened, starting seventy years earlier.
Scripture

Why Mark 3:24?

The lecture says Christ says this while defending himself against the charge that he casts out demons by the prince of demons. His argument is that a power at war with itself is destroying itself. The lecture says the fourteenth-century church supplied the demonstration.

If a kingdom is divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand." Mark 3:24 · World English Bible
Anagni, 1303

The claim and the arrest

Boniface VIII quarrelled with Philip IV of France about taxing the clergy. In 1302 Boniface issued Unam Sanctam, which says that submission to the Roman Pontiff is necessary to salvation. In September 1303 the king's minister broke into the papal residence at Anagni and held the pope prisoner for three days. No king came to the pope's aid.

Key idea The claim was absolute, and the power behind it was gone.
The shift

A world that had disappeared

The medieval papacy grew powerful in a Europe of weak, fragmented rulers, where it was the only institution with continental reach. By 1300 France and England were becoming real states with taxation, bureaucracies and national identity. The papacy went on making claims calibrated for a world that had disappeared.

Key idea An institution's authority can be gone while its self-description is unchanged.
Avignon

The church in France

In 1309 the papal court settled at Avignon, and it stayed until 1377 through seven popes, every one of them French. To an English, German or Italian Christian, the father of all Christians lived in a French-speaking town while French armies fought their own. Avignon also built the most sophisticated financial administration in Europe, with fees for appointments, appeals and dispensations. Ordinary Christians experienced the papacy chiefly as a bill.

Key idea Petrarch's phrase for it was the Babylon of the West.
1378

How the schism began

Gregory XI brought the papacy back to Rome in 1377 and died in March 1378. A Roman crowd demanded an Italian pope, and the cardinals elected Urban VI. By August the French cardinals had left Rome, declared the election invalid because it was made under the duress of the mob, and elected Clement VII at Avignon. The same cardinals had elected both men, and there was no court of appeal.

Key idea The only court of appeal was the office in dispute.
At a glance

Europe divides

Rome (Urban VI)

England, the Holy Roman Empire, Hungary, Poland, Scandinavia and most of Italy.

Avignon (Clement VII)

France, Scotland, Castile, Aragon and Naples.

The pastoral reality

Was the machinery of salvation working?

Each pope excommunicated the other and all his followers. Every absolution, Mass and marriage was performed under an authority that half of Christendom held to be void. There were saints on both sides: Catherine of Siena supported Urban VI, and Vincent Ferrer supported the Avignon line. The question of who held Christ's authority had become undecidable, and neither sanctity nor scholarship could decide it.

Key idea Once a claim cannot be checked, people stop treating it as a claim.
Pisa, 1409

From two popes to three

Cardinals from both sides summoned a council at Pisa, which deposed both popes and elected a third, Alexander V. Neither deposed pope accepted the ruling, so the council produced a schism among three. Pisa was summoned by cardinals, and its authority to depose rested on the theory it was trying to establish. The later Council of Constance succeeded partly because an emperor stood behind it.

Key idea Pisa was arguing in a circle.
Think about it

Authority that is no longer checkable

The lecture says an institution can lose its authority faster than it built it, and no one inside notices in time.

What would be a sign, in a church or group you know, that its claims can no longer be checked?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A quarrel about tax, a court that moved and stayed, a fee system and a disputed conclave each could be survived. Together they cost the papacy the assumption that its claims were checkable. Nobody inside saw the scale of it.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 14