FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH102E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution

In the fifteenth century the church came close to a constitution in which even the pope answered to a council. Then it lost the chance.

Medieval Church History

14 cards 21 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain the circumstances that made conciliarism plausible, and identify its roots in canon law rather than in rebellion.
  • Describe the conciliar ecclesiology of Jean Gerson and Pierre d'Ailly.
  • State what Haec Sancta and Frequens decreed, and why each mattered.
  • Explain how the Council of Basel discredited the movement, and what the papal recovery meant for the possibility of reform.
The claim

A council above everyone

In 1415 the Council of Constance passed a decree called Haec Sancta. It said that a general council holds its authority directly from Christ. It also said that everyone, including the pope, must obey it in matters of the faith, the ending of the schism, and the reform of the church in head and members. Then the council did what it said it could do. It removed three claimants to the papacy and installed a fourth, and Europe accepted the result.

Key idea The schism that nothing could touch for thirty-nine years was over.
Scripture

Why Acts 15:6?

The lecture says the Council of Jerusalem was the conciliarists' favourite text. They read it plainly: the apostles and elders met, argued and decided together. Their opponents read the same chapter and pointed out that James gave the ruling.

The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter." Acts 15:6 · World English Bible
Roots

Not a rebellion, but a lawyers' argument

Conciliarism grew out of canon law, the church's own legal tradition. The canon lawyers had asked for two centuries what to do about a heretical pope. Everyone agreed such a pope could not stay in office, so the church as a body, acting through a general council, must act. That was a narrow emergency rule. The schism turned it into a general theory, because the emergency had arrived and would not leave.

Key idea An emergency rule became a general theory.
The theory

Gerson and d'Ailly: the church is a body

Pierre d'Ailly and his pupil Jean Gerson worked out the main theory at the University of Paris. They argued that Christ gave authority to the church as a body. The pope holds real primacy, but it is given to him for the church, not over it. A power that destroys the church cannot be the power Christ gave, so the body may act through a general council when the head fails.

Key idea Authority in the church is given to serve the body.
Constance

For a moment it worked

Constance had the backing of Emperor Sigismund. It was also formally convened by one of the three claimants, which gave it a legitimacy that Pisa never had. John XXIII was deposed, Gregory XII abdicated, and Benedict XIII was left almost alone. In 1417 the council elected Martin V. In the same year it passed Frequens, which required general councils to meet at fixed intervals, so the council became a standing organ of government.

Key idea For a moment, the Western church had a working constitution.
A shadow

The same council burned Jan Hus

In the same council and in the same years, Jan Hus was burned. He had come to Constance under a safe conduct. The lecture asks the reader to hold both facts together. Constance was not a liberal parliament. It was a council of bishops solving a jurisdictional crisis, and it dealt with heresy the way such councils did.

Key idea Constance was a council of bishops, not a parliament.
Basel

How the movement lost

The Council of Basel opened in 1431 and began well. It came closer to a settlement with the Hussites than anyone had by force. Then it quarrelled with Pope Eugene IV, legislated against papal revenues and gave great weight to lower clergy and academics, and it lost its bishops. In 1439 it deposed Eugene IV and elected an antipope, Felix V. The movement that existed to end a schism had created one.

Key idea Basel did to the church what it existed to prevent.
At a glance

Constance and Basel

Constance (1414-18)

Backed by the emperor. It ended the schism, elected Martin V and passed Frequens. Reform in head and members was referred away and lost.

Basel (1431-49)

Convened under Frequens, then in open war with the pope. It deposed Eugene IV and elected an antipope, and it discredited conciliarism itself.

After 1460

Pius II issued Execrabilis, which forbade appealing from a pope to a council. No constitutional route remained.

The cost

Why the failure mattered

Haec Sancta claimed authority over three things: the faith, the schism and reform. The council delivered on the schism, but it never delivered on reform. Two things were then shown by demonstration. The church's abuses were widely acknowledged in public by its own leaders. And the church had no mechanism able to correct them against the will of the papal court. So later reformers did not try the constitution. They appealed over its head, to Scripture, to a prince and to the conscience of ordinary Christians.

Key idea The failure of reform from within is the precondition for the Reformation.
Think about it

Emergency rules

Conciliarism began as a narrow provision for the case of a heretical pope.

How does an emergency exception become a general theory, and what usually happens to it afterwards?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The fifteenth-century church came close to a constitutional institution, in which the highest office answers to a representative assembly, and then lost it. Constance ended the schism but did not deliver reform. Basel overreached, and Execrabilis closed the door in 1460. An institution needs ways to correct itself that outlast the crisis that created them.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 14