FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH201E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-1: The Avignon Papacy and the "Babylonian Captivity"

A papacy that claimed authority over every ruler spent sixty-eight years in a city beside the French crown, and the appearance of dependence did lasting damage.

The History of the Reformation

12 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Narrate the sequence from Boniface VIII's conflict with Philip IV of France through Clement V's election and the settlement of the papal court at Avignon in 1309.
  • Explain concretely what "Avignon papacy" changed and did not change — administration, taxation, and appointments, against the more limited claim that popes there were simply French puppets.
  • State why Petrarch's label "Babylonian Captivity" was a rhetorically loaded comparison, and what about it was fair and what was exaggeration.
  • Explain Walter Ullmann's argument that medieval papal authority was a historically constructed legal and political claim rather than a self-evident, unchanging fact — and why that reframing matters for reading the rest of this course.
The height

Boniface VIII and Unam Sanctam

In 1302 Pope Boniface VIII issued the bull Unam Sanctam during a bitter dispute with King Philip IV of France. It stated the medieval theory of papal authority in its most absolute form, using the image of two swords, spiritual and temporal, both ultimately in the church's hand. It closed with the sentence most often quoted: it is altogether necessary for salvation for every human creature to be subject to the Roman pontiff.

Key idea To see why Avignon felt like a fall, you have to see the height it fell from.
Anagni

The pope overpowered at home

In 1303 Philip's minister Guillaume de Nogaret, with an Italian noble family hostile to Boniface, seized the elderly pope at Anagni and held him for several days until townspeople freed him. Boniface died within weeks, and near-contemporaries linked the outrage of Anagni to the shock of his death. The lesson for the French crown was blunt: even a pope who claimed authority over kings could be overpowered by one king's agents.

Key idea The claim to universal authority had no army behind it.
1309

From Bordeaux to Avignon

After a conclave split for nearly a year between Italian and French factions, the Archbishop of Bordeaux was elected as Clement V. He was crowned at Lyon and never set foot in Rome. In 1309 he settled the papal court at Avignon, which was papal territory and not French royal territory, but lay on the Rhone within easy reach of the French court. Six more popes followed there until 1377, and all seven were French by birth.

Key idea A conclave dominated by French cardinals reliably elected French popes, and the effect on how Christendom saw the papacy was the same either way.
At a glance

What Avignon changed and what it did not

What it did not simply mean

It was not just decline. Several Avignon popes built a more centralized system of taxation and provision and ran a curia seen as more orderly than Rome's. Rome in 1305 was fought over by noble families and was not a safe seat.

What changed decisively

The appearance of independence. A papacy that had claimed every temporal power was subordinate to it now worked for seventy years in the shadow of one such power, and many in England, Germany and Italy came to believe the popes were French puppets.

Petrarch's label

Is "Babylonian Captivity" fair?

The poet Francesco Petrarch coined the phrase in the 1340s, writing from Avignon with evident disgust at the city's luxury. It recalls Judah's exile to Babylon and the seventy years Jeremiah names, close to the sixty-eight years at Avignon. It is an overstatement in two ways: the popes were not deported but made choices, and the papacy kept governing and was recognized by most of Western Christendom. It holds in two ways: dependence on one power's goodwill and a long absence from the traditional seat.

Key idea A careful student can say exactly where the comparison holds and where it does not.
Scripture

Why Matthew 20:25-28?

The lecture uses this text as the standard Jesus named for his followers' leadership, service and not the way the rulers of the nations exercise authority, against which readers can weigh the Avignon papacy's critics and defenders.

But Jesus summoned them, and said, "You know that the rulers of the nations lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. It shall not be so among you, but whoever desires to become great among you shall be your servant. Whoever desires to be first among you shall be your bondservant, even as the Son of Man came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many."" Matthew 20:25-28 · World English Bible
Ullmann

A claim that was built

The historian Walter Ullmann argued that medieval papal authority was a legal and political theory constructed over centuries by canon lawyers and popes responding to specific disputes. In his account a descending theory, with power flowing from God through the pope to rulers, competed with an ascending theory in which authority arises from the community. Later medievalists qualify his account in places. The point is that the authority asserted in 1302 was the product of a history, not a timeless fact.

Key idea This does not settle whether the claim was rightly built, only that its foundation was already a live question before the Reformation.
Think it through

Competence and legitimacy

Several Avignon popes were administratively effective even while their independence was widely doubted.

Can an institution be well run and yet still be in crisis? What does Avignon suggest about the difference between competence and legitimacy?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

After the highest papal claim in 1302, the court spent sixty-eight years at Avignon under seven French popes. The papacy kept working and was often efficient, but it looked dependent, and that appearance damaged its claim to universal authority. The lecture does not say the papal office was illegitimate. It asks readers to weigh leadership by the standard of service.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12