FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH201E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-1: What an Indulgence Actually Was

In the church's own doctrine an indulgence never forgave guilt. Luther's 1517 protest was about the gap between careful doctrine and the way one campaign was preached.

The History of the Reformation

11 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Distinguish, in the church's own sacramental theology, the forgiveness of guilt (through penance) from the remission of temporal punishment (through an indulgence), and explain what the "treasury of merit" was supposed to do.
  • Describe what Tetzel's preaching campaign was popularly understood to promise, and explain why that promise went beyond the doctrine an indulgence was theologically licensed to deliver.
  • State what the Ninety-Five Theses were, in their original form and purpose, and explain why calling them "a rejection of indulgences" or "a rejection of purgatory" misdescribes the document at this stage.
  • Explain why the gap between careful doctrine and aggressive marketing, rather than a flaw in the doctrine itself, is this lecture's real subject.
Two Latin words

Guilt and punishment

Scholastic theology distinguished culpa, the guilt of sin that estranges the sinner from God, from poena, the temporal punishment that sin leaves behind even once guilt is forgiven. The sacrament of penance handled guilt through contrition, confession and absolution. Punishment was handled through the penitent's own acts of satisfaction and, if those were insufficient, through purgatory, a painful but not damning purification after death.

Key idea The distinction long predates the indulgence system.
Scripture

Why 1 John 1:9?

The lecture uses this verse to name the transaction indulgence theology was never supposed to replace: forgiveness follows confession, and it is God, not a payment, who forgives and cleanses.

If we confess our sins, he is faithful and righteous to forgive us the sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness." 1 John 1:9 · World English Bible
The doctrine

What an indulgence did

An indulgence did not forgive guilt and did not replace confession. It reduced the temporal punishment still owed by an already-forgiven sinner, or by a soul in purgatory. The church claimed authority to do this by drawing on the treasury of merit, the merit of Christ together with that of Mary and the saints, using the pope's authority to bind and loose. On this account it was less like a bribe and more like drawing on an account of merit that already existed.

Key idea Indulgences addressed punishment, not guilt.
1517

What Tetzel's campaign was heard to promise

The St. Peter's Indulgence preached by Johann Tetzel in 1517 was marketed so directly that it alarmed some Catholic theologians as well as Luther. Contemporaries reported claims that it could free the dead from purgatory with near certainty and without the buyer's contrition. The rhyme about the coin in the coffer survives mainly through later, hostile reports, so we have no verified transcript of his words. Historians still agree that it captured how the campaign was popularly heard.

Key idea The grievance was a gap between doctrine and preaching.
At a glance

Doctrine and preaching

The church's careful doctrine

Guilt is forgiven through contrition, confession and absolution. An indulgence reduces only the remaining temporal punishment.

How the campaign was heard

A payment seemed to stand in for contrition and to release a soul from purgatory almost automatically.

The Theses

What they were in 1517

On 31 October 1517 Luther, an Augustinian friar and professor at Wittenberg, set out ninety-five propositions as an invitation to academic disputation in Latin. They were not a sermon to the laity or a declaration of new doctrine. Luther sent a copy to Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz, asking him to correct the preaching abuse. Whether they were nailed to a church door is debated, and the course need not resolve it.

Key idea Luther's target was the preaching, not indulgences or purgatory as such.
What Luther did not control

Printing and escalation

Someone translated the Theses into German and had them printed, and a printed document could spread across a large territory within weeks. Readers with no academic context took ninety-five hedged propositions as a sweeping challenge. The response Luther received was not correction but escalation, as Tetzel and allied theologians published counter-theses accusing Luther of heresy.

Key idea A text written for scholars reached ordinary readers.
One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Guilt is forgiven through penance, while an indulgence addressed temporal punishment. Luther's 1517 protest was about the gap between careful doctrine and aggressive marketing. Do not say Luther rejected indulgences, purgatory or papal authority in 1517, and do not say the church taught that forgiveness could be bought.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11