Lecture 7-2: Augsburg, 1518 — The First Interrogation
Luther's refusal to recant without scriptural proof was already fully present at Augsburg in 1518, nearly a year before Leipzig.
The History of the Reformation
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Luther's refusal to recant without scriptural proof was already fully present at Augsburg in 1518, nearly a year before Leipzig.
The History of the Reformation
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Augsburg (October 1518) predates Leipzig (June-July 1519) by the better part of a year. The chapter opens with Leipzig because it is the scene most readers already know. This lecture returns to Augsburg to correct an impression that Luther's position hardened suddenly under Eck's pressure. The refusal to recant without scriptural proof and the appeal beyond the pope's immediate judgment were both present nearly a year earlier.
Thomas Cajetan was one of the leading Dominican theologians in Europe, the author of a commentary on Aquinas's Summa. Pope Leo X wanted the matter resolved quietly, without disrupting the Emperor's diet or provoking Elector Frederick the Wise. Cajetan's brief was to hear Luther, press him toward recantation and avoid a public spectacle. That he failed reflects how far apart the two men's starting assumptions about authority already were.
Cajetan pressed the theology behind the indulgence controversy, and he invoked the decretal Unigenitus of Clement VI (1343), which grounded the treasury of merit in papal authority. Luther did not reject papal authority as such. He said this decretal could not settle the question by virtue of who had issued it, and he repeatedly asked to be shown his error from Scripture.
The lecture says Luther's logic at Augsburg ran along a structurally similar line: a decretal had to be tested against the commandment of God in Scripture, though Cajetan read Luther's use of it as a dangerous novelty.
He answered them, "Why do you also disobey the commandment of God because of your tradition?" Matthew 15:3 · World English Bible
The lecture says Luther's request to be shown his error from Scripture can be read as a claim to the Berean posture of testing teaching against Scripture, and it keeps open whether applying it to a cardinal's decretal is fair.
Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." Acts 17:11 · WEB
Asked Cajetan to show from Scripture where his reading was in error, and said a decretal could not settle the matter by its issuer's authority alone.
As a Thomist, he placed the right reading of Scripture within the church's living teaching office, so he saw the request itself as assuming the very point in dispute.
Luther had been summoned to answer for suspected heresy in Rome, which his allies treated as dangerous. Frederick secured his examination at Augsburg instead, under a safe-conduct from Emperor Maximilian. This had the same shape as the guarantee given to Hus before Constance in 1415. Luther left Augsburg by night once warned that his presence had become unsafe. Nothing suggests Cajetan personally intended violence.
Luther made a formal written appeal first from the pope poorly informed to the pope better informed. When that produced no relief, he appealed to a future general council. Conciliarism had been decisively weakened at the Fifth Lateran Council only a year or two earlier, so the appeal's force outran its practical prospects. It sounded like due process within the system.
At Augsburg in 1518, Cajetan, a leading Thomist, pressed Luther to recant. Luther did not deny papal authority but asked to be shown his error from Scripture, and he appealed first to the pope better informed and then to a future council. The second appeal had little practical weight because conciliarism was already weak.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.