FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH201E · Chapter 14

Lecture 14-2: A Capital Crime — Zurich, Rome, and the Drowning of Felix Manz

Two opposed governments reached the same verdict. The reason lay partly in doctrine and partly in how church and citizenship were joined.

The History of the Reformation

12 cards 17 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why both Reformed and Catholic authorities treated rebaptism as a capital crime, distinguishing the specifically theological objection from the social and political one, and state why the second reason mattered even where the first did not fully apply.
  • Narrate the circumstances of Felix Manz's 1527 execution accurately, including the method chosen and why contemporaries and later historians read that method as a deliberate, grim theological statement.
  • Evaluate, without resolving for the reader, whether the "church and citizenship inseparable" argument for suppressing Anabaptism was a serious, defensible concern for a sixteenth-century government or primarily a pretext for persecuting an unwelcome minority — and explain what evidence would count toward each answer.
Scripture

Why Acts 2:38?

The lecture pairs this verse with Acts 2:41 and says the two, read together, carried opposite weight for the two sides of the dispute.

Peter said to them, 'Repent, and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.'" Acts 2:38 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Acts 2:41?

The lecture says the Swiss Brethren read its sequence of hearing, receiving gladly and being baptized as voluntary, confession-based membership. Their opponents read the crowd's incorporation at once as compatible with a whole community being received together.

Then those who gladly received his word were baptized. There were added that day about three thousand souls." Acts 2:41 · WEB
One verdict

Zurich and the Catholic authorities

Zurich first used banishment and fines and made rebaptism a capital crime only in March 1526. Catholic authorities held that a validly baptized infant had received real grace, so rebaptism denied that a sacrament does what the church teaches. They also reused a late Roman law, from the Codex of Justinian, against Donatist rebaptism. These powers agreed on almost nothing else about baptism, the Mass or the papacy.

Key idea That opposed powers reached the same judgment suggests something besides sacramental theology was at work.
The social reason

Baptism and citizenship

In nearly every sixteenth-century city, baptism made an infant a member of the political community as well as the church. There was in practice no register of citizens separate from the baptismal register. A movement that made baptism voluntary and adult proposed a church membership that no longer coincided with civic membership. No government of the period had a category for that which did not look like sedition.

Key idea A quiet act of pouring water could be treated as a threat to civic order.
5 January 1527

The drowning of Felix Manz

Felix Manz had been repeatedly arrested and banished, and returned each time. Arrested again in December 1526, he was sentenced under the 1526 mandate, the first time it was carried to execution. He was drowned in the Limmat River, a method read as a grim "third baptism". He reportedly sang a psalm on the way, and his mother and brother called out encouragement from the bank.

Key idea He was the first Anabaptist executed by an explicitly Protestant government.
Beyond Zurich

A wider pattern

Zurich's action set a precedent that other Reformed and Lutheran territories followed with varying enthusiasm. Catholic authorities in South Germany, Austria and Moravia carried out executions by fire, sword and drowning, on a scale the lecture says likely exceeded Zurich's. The early history of the Radical Reformation is, more than the other movements in the course, a history of its martyrs' names and dates.

Key idea The persecutors included every other tradition a reader might belong to.
At a glance

Two governments, one fear

Reformed Zurich

Baptism was entry into a Christian civic-religious community. Capital mandate in March 1526 and first execution, Felix Manz, in 1527.

Catholic territories

Baptism was objective sacramental grace, validly conferred. Legal basis was reused Roman law against Donatist rebaptism.

Think it over

Explaining without excusing

The lecture says sixteenth-century governments had a coherent structural reason for their fear, and that killing people for baptizing as adults was a moral catastrophe regardless.

What evidence would count toward the fear being serious, and what evidence toward its being a pretext?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Reformed and Catholic authorities both made rebaptism a capital crime, partly for sacramental reasons and partly because baptism joined church membership to civic membership. Felix Manz was drowned in the Limmat on 5 January 1527. The lecture asks readers to avoid both excusing the killing and reducing the fear behind it to simple bigotry.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12