FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved

Westphalia was not a reconciliation. It built machinery for permanent disagreement among three confessions, and it pushed theologians to ask how much they must agree on.

The Church in the Modern World

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe what the Peace of Westphalia changed in the political and legal order of the Empire, including the recognition of the Reformed confession, and identify what the treaty is often wrongly credited with.
  • Explain how the settlement entrenched the territorial state church, and state both the loss and the gain that followed for the churches.
  • Distinguish toleration of necessity from a rights-based freedom of religion, naming who was covered by the first and who was not.
  • Explain how the discrediting of confessional warfare pushed theologians toward a distinction between fundamental articles and adiaphora, and describe the resistance that attempt met.
The shape of the peace

Two towns, five years

Catholic delegations sat at Münster and Protestant delegations at Osnabrück, twenty-five miles apart. Months went on questions of precedence before substance could be discussed. Westphalia was a set of arrangements by parties who still regarded each other as being in serious religious error. It was durable precisely because it did not require anyone to change their mind.

Key idea The treaties were signed on 24 October 1648.
Scripture

Why Romans 12:18?

The lecture notes that Paul limits his sentence twice: if it is possible, and as much as it is up to you. It says this describes what you do when the other party may not cooperate, which suits 1648.

If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." Romans 12:18 · World English Bible
At a glance

What the treaty did

Calvinism became legal

The Reformed confession was recognised alongside Catholic and Lutheran.

A date replaced an argument

The Normaljahr fixed ownership by whoever lawfully held a church or right on 1 January 1624. Everyone could see the date was arbitrary, and that was the point.

Conversion curtailed

A ruler who changed faith no longer dragged his subjects with him, and subjects received the right to emigrate with their property.

Bi-confessional institutions

Imperial courts were staffed evenly, and in religious matters the diet separated into two bodies and settled by agreement.

A correction

What the treaty is wrongly credited with

A common story says 1648 abolished the medieval order and created sovereign states. The lecture calls the strong form of that story an invention, built in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. What can be said is more modest. The papacy's capacity to shape Europe's political order was visibly gone, and religious uniformity had ceased to be a realistic aim. Innocent X declared the religious terms void in the brief Zelo Domus Dei, and the protest was disregarded.

Key idea When a historical connection is very elegant, suspect that it is yours and not history's.
At a glance

The state church: cost and gain

What it cost

A church that depends on the state acquires the state's interests. Appointments become patronage, and membership becomes a civil status held by everyone born in the territory.

What it bought

It ended the killing, funded parishes and schools in ruined districts, and let more than one confession exist in the same polity.

Old toleration

Not modern religious freedom

Toleration in 1648 protected confessions, not consciences. It covered three confessions and no others: Anabaptists, Mennonites, Schwenkfelders, anti-Trinitarians and Jews received nothing. It rested on calculation, not conviction, since suppressing error had turned out to cost more than the Empire could pay. It was also reversible: the Edict of Nantes was revoked in 1685.

Key idea When you read that 1648 established toleration, ask: for whom?
Sorting doctrines

Essentials and adiaphora

Once force could not settle doctrine, theologians asked how much they must agree on. Rupertus Meldenius wrote the motto: in necessary things unity, in unnecessary things liberty, in both charity. Georg Calixt proposed the Apostles' Creed and the first five centuries as a basis for unity. Abraham Calov and the Wittenberg faculty answered by accusing him of syncretism and asking who decides what is fundamental.

Key idea The lecture says deciding what you will not divide over also decides what you will not defend.
Think about it

Who decides?

Calov asked Calixt who decides what counts as a fundamental article.

Give your answer. Then name one doctrine you regard as non-essential that a Christian you respect regards as essential.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Westphalia built machinery for permanent disagreement among three confessions without asking anyone to change their mind. Its toleration was not modern religious freedom. Exhaustion achieved what charity had not, so when you decide what to divide over, ask who decides what is fundamental.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12