FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy

Denominationalism was an accommodation to a defeat: practice came first and theology came afterwards. It is a Protestant arrangement, and it both gained and cost.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain how the ideal of a single visible church broke down through the Reformation and the Thirty Years War, and what replaced it in practice before anything replaced it in theory.
  • Explain what the term denomination did that sect and heresy could not, and what the shift in vocabulary conceded.
  • Explain how the maxim "in essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty" supplied the theological warrant for denominational coexistence, and identify the unresolved question at its centre.
  • Describe the rise of voluntary religion and the road from denominational coexistence to a pluralist society — and assess what that coexistence cost.
A new word

From verdict to name

In the sixteenth century English gave you sect, faction and heresy for a body you did not belong to. All three are verdicts. By the mid-eighteenth century the phrase Christians of every denomination was in ordinary use, and denominare simply means to name. What changed was the working assumption: from the other body is an infection to be removed, to the other body will be there next year.

Key idea Changing a word is not the same as changing a mind.
For whom?

A Protestant arrangement

The lecture says denominationalism is a Protestant arrangement and the lecture is about Protestants. The Catholic Church does not understand itself as one denomination among others, and neither does an Orthodox church. Both hold that they are the Church. The lecture says this is a difference of position, not a failure to keep up.

Key idea Lumen Gentium is the lecture's suggested source for the Catholic account.
One church ends

A hundred and thirty years of evidence

Medieval Western Europe held that there is one church, it is visible, and it covers Christian society. Luther, Calvin and Cranmer all held it too, and none set out to found a denomination. What ended the proposition was not an argument but evidence. By 1650 Catholics had not eliminated Protestants, and Lutherans had not eliminated Calvinists.

Key idea The practice came first and the theology came afterwards to explain it.
Scripture

Why 1 Corinthians 12:12?

The lecture says this passage is quoted more often than any other in defence of denominations. It says the passage will not quite do that work, because Paul's members belong to one body and cannot survive apart.

For as the body is one, and has many members, and all the members of the body, being many, are one body; so also is Christ." 1 Corinthians 12:12 · World English Bible
At a glance

What the word conceded

It conceded

The visible church is divided and will remain so, as the working condition of Christian life and not a temporary scandal.

It did not concede

That doctrine is unimportant. A Presbyterian who calls a Baptist congregation a denomination has not become indifferent to baptism.

At a glance

The load-bearing distinction

It protects the centre

Trinity, incarnation, the authority of Scripture, justification and the resurrection of the body. A body that denies the core is not another denomination.

It releases the periphery

Church government, infant baptism, liturgical form, the manner of Christ's presence in the Supper, vestments and hymnody.

The open question

Who decides which list a doctrine goes on? There is no neutral court, so each body draws the line itself.

A hard case

The framework can be abused

In 1844 the Methodist Episcopal Church split over whether a bishop might own slaves. In 1845 the Baptists split over whether a slaveholder might be a missionary. The southern argument used the essentials language: slavery was a civil question, not a matter of the gospel. A distinction invented to stop Christians killing each other over the Supper was used within two centuries to avoid confronting slavery.

Key idea The lecture marks as disputed whether the tool or its use was at fault.
Voluntary religion

Belonging becomes a choice

Under a territorial establishment, church membership is a civil status. Where several bodies operate and none can compel, a person joins. The gains are a church of people who are there on purpose and the removal of the state's hand from religion. The costs are pressure to be attractive and competition between churches. H. Richard Niebuhr argued that the real dividing lines run along class, race, region and national origin more than doctrine.

Key idea Competition also drove schools, hospitals, printing and missionary societies.
Think about it

Test your own list

Write down three doctrines you regard as essential and three you regard as non-essential.

What would it cost you, personally and socially, to move one item from the second list to the first? Does the cost explain the list?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Denominationalism was an accommodation to a defeat, with practice first and theology afterwards. It protects a core and releases the rest, but no neutral court decides which is which. Catholic and Orthodox churches do not use the word of themselves. Test your own list of essentials by what it would cost you to move one item.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13