FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America

The First Great Awakening gave the colonies a test for revival, new colleges and new Christian voices. It also left slavery standing, and the lecture says so plainly.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 27 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe the condition of colonial churches before the revivals — the Half-Way Covenant, the shortage of clergy, the actual figures for church adherence — and assess how far "spiritual decline" is a description and how far it is a revivalist's argument.
  • Explain Edwards's theological contribution, especially the test for genuine religion he sets out in Religious Affections, and why he needed such a test.
  • Explain what Whitefield did that was new, how his fame was manufactured, and why his revival was inseparable from his position on slavery.
  • Analyse the Awakening's results: the New Light and Old Light division, the new colleges, the beginnings of Black and Native Christianity in the colonies, and the historians' argument about whether "the Great Awakening" is a real event or a label applied afterwards.
Before the revivals

Take the decline seriously, hold it loosely

The Half-Way Covenant of 1662 let baptised but unconverted adults present their children for baptism while withholding the Table from them. That was a real compromise, and a church that has to invent half-membership is telling you something. But colonial adherence had probably never been as high as the pious picture suggests. Every awakening writes the period before it as dark, and that is not proof that it was.

Key idea The darkness was partly painted in afterwards.
Northampton

A revival that could be copied

In the winter of 1734–35 about three hundred people in Edwards's Northampton professed conversion. He wrote it up as A Faithful Narrative of the Surprising Work of God in 1737. It was published in London and circulated across the Atlantic world as a template. Revivals became imitable because Edwards described one in print.

Key idea Part of the Awakening's reach came from a printed account.
Scripture

Why Isaiah 26:13?

The lecture reads this verse against a revival that took place inside a slave society. It says the verse asks who had dominion over whom, and whose name was actually being confessed by whom.

Yahweh our God, other lords besides you have had dominion over us, but by you only will we make mention of your name." Isaiah 26:13 · World English Bible
At a glance

Edwards's test in Religious Affections

Twelve signs prove nothing

Intensity of feeling, bodily effects, fluency, texts coming to mind, time in religious duties and confident assurance are compatible with both a genuine work and a counterfeit.

What does distinguish

Genuine affection arises from a perception of God's own excellence. It produces humility and a changed disposition, and above all Christian practice sustained over time.

The answer

Watch the life

Edwards ends by relocating the evidence outside the experience. The one reliable test of an inward change is what a person is still doing three years later. It answers the problem of the whole chapter: if the mark of faith is inward, who can check it? Nobody can check the inside, so watch the life instead.

Key idea Edwards moved the evidence from the meeting to the years after.
Whitefield

A new kind of preacher

George Whitefield preached outdoors to enormous crowds, without notes and across denominational lines. He sent advance notice of his tours to newspapers and published his journals as he went. His fame was manufactured by him with the newest communications technology. Because he preached the new birth rather than a confession, he detached religious authority from parish pulpits. That was democratising, and it was also the engine of schism.

Key idea The same act democratised authority and divided churches.
Slavery

Both of those are Whitefield

Whitefield judged that Bethesda could not be made to pay without enslaved labour. He argued for years that Georgia's prohibition should be lifted and welcomed its repeal in 1751. In 1740 he also wrote a public letter insisting that Black people had souls, were capable of conversion, and must be taught. The lecture says this was not simply the view of his time, since Benjamin Lay, John Woolman and later Wesley said otherwise.

Key idea The judgement was available to people of his own century.
At a glance

What the Awakening produced

New Lights and Old Lights

The two parties held the same confession. They divided over what counts as evidence of God's work and who may say so.

Colleges

New Light Presbyterians founded the College of New Jersey, later Princeton, in 1746. Brown, Rutgers and Dartmouth have roots in the same soil.

Black and Native Christianity

The revivals reached Black and Native communities in new numbers. Samson Occom, a Mohegan, became a minister and a missionary.

Think about it

Apply the twelve signs

Edwards says intensity, bodily effects, fluency and confident assurance are all compatible with a counterfeit.

Apply his twelve negative signs to a religious gathering you have attended. What survives?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Edwards's test is that inward experience cannot be checked from outside, so you watch the life. Whitefield preached to enslaved people and also helped fasten slavery onto a colony that had banned it. The lecture says all of that is one story. Historians also dispute whether the Awakening was a single event.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13