FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 5

Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle

Missions and empires rose together between 1870 and 1914. Both columns of the record are documented, and the argument does not settle.

The Church in the Modern World

14 cards 29 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Give a concrete account of how nineteenth-century missionary expansion and imperial expansion became entangled — routes, law, money, personnel and ideology — rather than asserting the connection in general terms.
  • Explain what "the civilising mission" did to local cultures in practice, using named cases, and distinguish it from the gospel it was carried alongside.
  • Give named examples of missionaries and mission-formed Christians who resisted colonial power, and say what made resistance possible in some cases and not others.
  • State the main scholarly positions on missions and empire — Stanley, Sanneh, Walls, the Comaroffs — well enough that an advocate of each would accept your summary, and identify what evidence would count for or against each.
The fact

Two curves rise together

Between about 1870 and 1914 the European powers took direct control of most of Africa and much of Southeast Asia and the Pacific. Those same decades were the peak of Protestant and Catholic missionary sending. The lecture treats this as a live question, because it shapes what people say about their own churches today. It takes three passes: missions that served empire, missions that checked it, and the translation argument.

Key idea The overlap is a fact. What it means is the argument.
Scripture

Why Matthew 10:16?

The lecture says this image is usually read backwards in this context. Jesus sends his messengers defenceless, with shrewdness and no harm as their only equipment, and the lecture sets that beside a missionary position backed by treaties and consuls.

Behold, I send you out as sheep in the midst of wolves. Therefore be wise as serpents, and harmless as doves." Matthew 10:16 · World English Bible
Five mechanisms

How they became entangled

The lecture names five joints. Routes: missionaries went where imperial transport and law made going possible. Law: treaty clauses and mission spheres decided who could work where. Money and personnel: societies raised funds from a public formed by imperial newspapers. Services: missions staffed many schools and hospitals, often with subsidy. Ideology: the gospel's claim that all need it fused with a racial hierarchy, so "these people need the gospel" began to mean "these people need us."

Key idea Routes, law, money, services and ideology.
Civilising

The Kikuyu case, 1929

In Kenya the Church of Scotland Mission and others required members to renounce female circumcision, in a setting where Kikuyu land had already been taken for settlers. Many members left, independent schools and churches were founded, and the dispute fed Kikuyu political organisation. The lecture notes that the opposition to the practice was later vindicated by African-led campaigns. Even so, pressing it by ultimatum produced a schism, since being right about the thing is not the same as being right about how to press it.

Key idea A right aim pressed by a harmful method.
A reversal

Samuel Ajayi Crowther

Crowther was a Yoruba boy taken by slave raiders, freed at sea and landed at Freetown. He became a linguist, led the Yoruba Bible translation, and in 1864 became the first African Anglican bishop. This followed Henry Venn's three-self policy: a self-governing, self-supporting, self-propagating native church. After Venn's death, a new generation of CMS men investigated Crowther's clergy and reduced his authority. He was succeeded by a European bishop, and the lecture says the policy did not fail. It was reversed.

Key idea The claim that Africans were not ready was made after the fact.
At a glance

Served empire, checked empire

Served empire

Treaty clauses and consular protection, funds raised in the metropole, culture treated as an obstacle, and the Crowther reversal of 1890.

Checked empire

Sheppard and the Harrises exposed the Congo, missionaries opposed opium and sati, and mission schools trained leaders such as Chilembwe, Azariah, Kenyatta, Nkrumah and Mandela.

The sharpest case

William Wadé Harris

Harris was a Liberian preacher in no European society's employ. He walked through the Ivory Coast and the Gold Coast in 1913-15 and brought perhaps a hundred thousand people to Christian faith in about eighteen months. That was more than all the European missions in the region had managed in decades. The French authorities arrested and deported him. The lecture calls this the sharpest case: the most effective evangelist in West African history was an African working independently, whom the colonial state treated as a threat.

Key idea The colonial state treated an independent African evangelist as a threat.
At a glance

Four scholarly positions

Comaroffs

Mission colonised consciousness (time, work, body, household, language) by consent, and so reached deeper than force.

Stanley

The relationship varied. It must be settled case by case, because the sweeping indictment and the sweeping vindication both fail.

Sanneh

Translating Scripture into the vernacular says a people's language is adequate to God, and gives them a standard to judge the ruler by.

Walls

Christianity has no permanent centre. Each new culture translates it, with an indigenizing principle and a pilgrim principle together.

A rule for reading

The honest verdict is not a verdict

The lecture says vernacular Christianity grew fastest after the missionaries left, which is a point for Sanneh and Walls. It also says this does not dispose of the Comaroffs' evidence about what mission did to Tswana time, dress, work and family. Both can be true: a movement can restructure a society in the coloniser's image and hand that society the tools to reject the coloniser. So ask of each mission, each decade and each person which of the two it was doing.

Key idea Expect the answer to be both.
Think about it

Who pays?

The Crowther case turns on the fact that the Niger Mission's money came from London.

Name the funding relationships in your own church or agency. If a disagreement became serious, who would be able to act on whom?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Missions and empire were tied by specific mechanisms, yet missions also resisted empire and translated Scripture into local languages. Both columns are documented, so each case needs its own reading. Money still decides who holds power, and the people evangelised are now the church.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 14