The textbook story says Barth read the manifesto of the ninety-three in October 1914, concluded liberal theology had failed, and wrote Romans. Historians such as Bruce McCormack show something messier. Barth was already unsettled in Safenwil by representing textile workers against factory owners. He drew on Blumhardt, Overbeck, Kierkegaard and Dostoevsky, and the decisive theological moves came in the 1920s and later. Catastrophe produces silence and then a long argument, not good theology automatically.
Key idea The war made it impossible to go back. It did not say where to go.