FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word

Barth's Romans began as a preacher's problem. It holds God's No and God's Yes together, and says the Word of God comes in three forms.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 23 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Account for Barth's break with the theology he was trained in, and explain why the popular version of that break — a single manifesto, a single day — is at best a compression.
  • State what the second edition of Romans claimed and why contemporaries found it violent, including the sense of the phrase "infinite qualitative distinction".
  • Explain dialectical theology as the holding together of God's No and God's Yes, and say why the No exists for the sake of the Yes rather than the other way round.
  • List and explain the threefold form of the Word of God, and show what changes in preaching and in the reading of Scripture if the order is taken seriously.
The story

A conversion too tidy to be true

The textbook story says Barth read the manifesto of the ninety-three in October 1914, concluded liberal theology had failed, and wrote Romans. Historians such as Bruce McCormack show something messier. Barth was already unsettled in Safenwil by representing textile workers against factory owners. He drew on Blumhardt, Overbeck, Kierkegaard and Dostoevsky, and the decisive theological moves came in the 1920s and later. Catastrophe produces silence and then a long argument, not good theology automatically.

Key idea The war made it impossible to go back. It did not say where to go.
Where it began

The problem of the Sunday morning

Barth had to preach every week to a village congregation. He had been trained to preach the community's religious consciousness and the moral significance of Jesus. In the pulpit he found none of it was news: it was the congregation's own best thoughts with a scriptural decoration. So he went back to the text and tried to read it as though it might say something he had not put there.

Key idea Neo-orthodoxy began as a preacher's problem.
Scripture

Why Romans 1:17?

The lecture says the whole book turns on this verse, and Barth's question is whose righteousness. If it is a standard we are measured against, it is bad news. If it is God's own saving action from God's side, it is the opposite, and Barth read the letter that way.

For in it is revealed God’s righteousness from faith to faith. As it is written, “But the righteous shall live by faith.”" Romans 1:17 · World English Bible
What Romans claimed

The infinite qualitative distinction

Barth borrowed from Kierkegaard the phrase the infinite qualitative distinction between time and eternity. It is mainly a claim about direction. Religion runs from below upwards: it climbs, aspires and purifies. Revelation runs from above downwards: it arrives. So everything human in religion is put under judgement, and Christianity is not exempt. Karl Adam, a Catholic, said the book fell like a bombshell on the playground of the theologians.

Key idea Religion climbs. Revelation descends.
At a glance

The No and the Yes

The No

God's judgement falls on every human attempt to secure God, including morality, religion, the church and this theology.

The Yes

In Jesus Christ, God crosses the distinction from the other side. The cross speaks the No in full, and the resurrection speaks the Yes to the same people.

The order

The No exists for the sake of the Yes

This is the opposite of the usual caricature of Barth as saying no to everything. In the Church Dogmatics he argues that Jesus Christ is both the electing God and the rejected man, so judgement falls where grace is given. Read that way, the severity of Romans is the removal of every alternative to grace. Barth later thought the second edition had too much No. A student who stops at Romans has read the shout and skipped the argument.

Key idea Do not stop at the shout.
A misquoted claim

Religion as unbelief

In Church Dogmatics I/2, Barth wrote that religion is unbelief. Here religion means the human enterprise of reaching and securing God, not prayer, liturgy or church attendance. The German word Aufhebung carries three senses: to cancel, to lift up and to preserve. Revelation cancels religion as a way to God and preserves it as the form in which grace meets us. The target was the Protestant church of his own country.

Key idea The claim is aimed inward, and it has three senses.
At a glance

The Word of God in three forms

Revealed

Jesus Christ. The Word is first a person and an event, not a text.

Written

Holy Scripture, the prophetic and apostolic witness to that event, and a genuinely human book.

Preached

The sermon. Human speech that God may take up and make the vehicle of God's own address.

Think about it

News or best thoughts?

Barth's difficulty began in a pulpit, not a library.

Describe a sermon you have heard that gave the congregation its own best thoughts back with a scriptural decoration. What would have had to change for it to be news?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

For Barth, God speaks from above, not through human ascent. The No on every human attempt to secure God exists for the sake of the Yes in Jesus Christ. The Word of God comes in three forms in order: revealed, written and preached.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13