FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen

Barmen is the most important Protestant confession of the twentieth century, and it is brave. It also says nothing about the Jews.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 24 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe how the German Christian movement captured the machinery of German Protestantism, and explain the theological claim — not merely the political one — that made it possible.
  • Explain what the Confessing Church was, what actually triggered its formation, and how divided and limited it was.
  • Summarise the six theses of the Barmen Declaration, including the form each thesis takes and what each one rejects.
  • State what Barmen did not address, explain why, and assess what the omission means for how the Declaration should be used today.
The theology behind it

What the German Christians believed

Many German Christians were sincere, and their position had a theology. God creates peoples, and a nation's blood, language and land are given by God, so God's will can be read in them. On that view, a church that refuses to align with the nation's renewal refuses God. The lecture says this is the same method as the theology of 6-1, God known through the highest values of a culture, pushed to a conclusion its earlier exponents would have found monstrous.

Key idea They reached their conclusion without breaking the method.
How far they got

The Aryan Paragraph

In the church elections of July 1933, held under heavy Nazi pressure, German Christian candidates won around two-thirds of the seats. Ludwig Müller was installed as Reich Bishop in September. In the same month the Prussian general synod voted to apply the Aryan Paragraph to church office, so clergy of Jewish descent were to be removed. The lecture says this is the specific act that started the resistance.

Key idea The trigger was racial law applied inside the church.
The Confessing Church

A church fight, not a resistance movement

Martin Niemöller founded the Pastors' Emergency League in September 1933, and out of it came the Confessing Church. The lecture gives four qualifications. It was a minority: of about 18,000 pastors, roughly 3,000 were on each side and the large majority in neither. It was divided between a radical and a moderate wing. It was patriotic. And its resistance eroded, as when many pastors swore an oath to Hitler in 1938.

Key idea Its objection was to the regime inside the church.
Scripture

Why Acts 5:29?

The lecture says the Confessing Church quoted this verse constantly. It points out that the apostles refuse one order, to stop preaching about Jesus, so the refusal is narrow, which describes both the strength and the limit of Barmen.

But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men." Acts 5:29 · World English Bible
Barmen, 29-31 May 1934

One confession from three traditions

The synod met in the Gemarke church in Barmen. Lutherans, Reformed and united churches, who had spent four centuries unable to agree about the Lord's Supper, signed one confession. Karl Barth, Hans Asmussen and Thomas Breit drafted it. Every one of the six theses has three parts: a passage of Scripture, a positive statement of what the church confesses, and a rejection beginning "We reject the false doctrine, as though..."

Key idea Scripture, confession, rejection, six times.
The form

Refuting without naming

Barmen never mentions Hitler, the party, the Reich Bishop or the Aryan Paragraph. It states what the church believes and then names the error that contradicts it. The German Christians are refuted without being addressed. The lecture calls this both a theological decision and, under a regime that read everything, a practical one.

Key idea It argues from doctrine, never from politics.
At a glance

Two of the six theses

Thesis I: Christ the one Word

It rejects the idea that the church could recognise other events, powers, figures and truths as God's revelation alongside Christ. The lecture calls it the hinge of the document, aimed at the claim that the nation and its hour are revelation.

Thesis V: the limited state

It affirms the state's task of justice and peace, and thanks God for it. It rejects the state becoming the single and total order of life. The lecture says it is not revolutionary: it denies totality.

What Barmen does not say

No mention of the Jews

Barmen contains no reference to the Jews, to the Aryan Paragraph, to the 1933 boycott or to the persecution that was fourteen months old. The Confessing Church defended the church's right to define membership by baptism rather than blood. The lecture says that is a real principle but is not the same as defending Jews. Barth later wrote that he felt guilty for not having made the question decisive. Stuttgart in 1945 also did not name the Jews. The Berlin-Weissensee synod of 1950 was the first to do so.

Key idea Use Barmen accurately: a good answer to one question, none to another.
Think about it

Who is outside the room?

The Confessing Church resisted when the threat entered its own house and largely did not when it did not.

Where is the line of your own church's house drawn, and who is currently outside it?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Barmen answers one question well: the church may not take its message or its order from an ideology, because Christ alone is its Word and Lord. It was not a revolutionary document, and it did not speak for the Jews. When told a church stood firm, ask what it stood firm about, and who was left outside the room.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13