FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine

Between 1906 and 1916 a revival became a set of denominations with a written doctrinal test. Tongues as initial evidence is still a live question, and four positions are worth stating fairly.

The Church in the Modern World

12 cards 24 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what early Pentecostals meant by restorationism, and how it shaped their claim to be recovering the church of Acts rather than founding something new.
  • Describe how the doctrine of tongues as initial evidence was formulated, the texts it rests on, and what work it was doing for a movement that needed a boundary.
  • Explain how the understanding of tongues shifted from missionary languages to a gift of prayer, and why that revision was forced.
  • State the cessationist case and the Pentecostal reply, and describe how the movement organised into denominations — including the divisions of 1910 and 1916.
Self-understanding

We are not new

Early Pentecostals did not think of themselves as founding a denomination. They thought they were witnessing the return of something the church had mislaid. On this restorationist reading, the church of Acts had apostles, prophets, healings and tongues, the gifts fell silent after the apostolic age, and God was now restoring them in the last days. They claimed the opposite of novelty: they were the old thing.

Key idea The movement saw itself as recovering Acts, not inventing something.
Doctrine

Tongues as initial evidence

The distinctive Pentecostal doctrine is that the baptism in the Holy Spirit is an experience distinct from and normally subsequent to conversion. The first outward sign that it has occurred is speaking in tongues. The scriptural case is drawn almost entirely from Acts. The lecture asks what the doctrine was for: it gave the seeker a finish line, and it gave a scattered movement a boundary.

Key idea A doctrine is also a piece of social equipment.
Scripture

Why Acts 2:4?

The lecture says every position it sets out accepts this verse. The disagreement is whether it describes one founding morning or a pattern the church should expect to repeat, and the verse itself does not say which.

They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak." Acts 2:4 · World English Bible
A revision

From missionary languages to a language of prayer

Parham's theory was that tongues were real foreign languages given for missionary work. Missionaries went out expecting to preach on arrival without study, and it did not work. Pentecostals did not abandon tongues. They re-described them with Paul, using 1 Corinthians 14 and Romans 8:26, as a language of prayer addressed to God.

Key idea Claim, public failure, exegetical revision, retained core.
At a glance

Four ways of reading the same texts

Classical Pentecostal

Spirit baptism is a distinct experience after conversion, for power in witness. Tongues is its initial physical evidence. In Acts 10 the evidence is what persuades Peter's companions.

Continuationist, no initial evidence

The gifts were never withdrawn, but requiring tongues as the sign goes beyond the texts. Gordon Fee argued that Acts is narrative, and narrative does not by itself establish a norm.

Cessationist

The revelatory and miraculous gifts authenticated the apostles while the New Testament was being given. That function ended when the apostolic foundation was laid.

Catholic Charismatic

Baptism in the Spirit is not a second baptism. The Spirit is given in baptism and confirmation, and in the renewal a grace already given is released and becomes conscious.

First split

Sanctification, 1910 to 1914

Early Pentecostals inherited a three-stage scheme: conversion, entire sanctification, then Spirit baptism. In 1910 William H. Durham began preaching the finished work of Calvary, which left two stages. The Wesleyan-Holiness bodies kept three. The Assemblies of God was formed largely from the two-stage side at Hot Springs, Arkansas, in April 1914.

Key idea Definition had a price within eight years of Azusa.
Second split

The New Issue, 1913 to 1916

In 1913 a preacher at Arroyo Seco noticed that the baptisms in Acts are performed in the name of Jesus Christ. From this grew a reading in which Father, Son and Spirit are modes of the one God who is Jesus. The 1916 general council adopted the Statement of Fundamental Truths partly to stop it, and roughly a quarter of the fellowship's ministers left or were removed. They formed the Oneness bodies that exist today.

Key idea A body that defines itself to survive loses those outside the definition.
Think about it

Stating a view you do not hold

The lecture does not ask you to choose among the four positions.

Can you state one position you do not hold so accurately that someone who holds it would say, yes, that is what I think?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Between 1906 and 1916 an experience became a doctrine and a revival became denominations. That gave the movement durability, and it cost the improvised, lay quality of Azusa Street and a good number of the people who had been there. Whether tongues is the initial evidence of Spirit baptism is still disputed among people who all take Scripture as their authority.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12