FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches

The second wave carried the Pentecostal experience into the old churches, and most of its people stayed where they were. It was a renewal, not a schism, and it had real costs.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 24 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what distinguishes the charismatic movement from classical Pentecostalism — in social composition, in vocabulary, and above all in the decision to stay.
  • Describe the Bennett affair of 1960 and explain why an announcement in a suburban parish became a denominational event.
  • Explain how the historic churches integrated the gifts with sacrament, liturgy and church order, and what theological account they gave of Spirit baptism in order to do it.
  • Describe the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from 1967 and assess the ecumenical significance and the limits of the second wave, including the abuses of the 1970s.
A different room

Azusa Street and Van Nuys

The experience reported at Van Nuys in 1960 was recognisably the same as at Azusa Street in 1906. Almost everything else was different. The people involved generally declined the word Pentecostal and adopted charismatic, from charismata, the gifts. They claimed the gifts without claiming the denomination.

Key idea The same experience in a different room made a different movement.
Staying put

The decision to stay

Classical Pentecostals had left, or been pushed out, and built. Charismatics stayed. A Lutheran who began praying in tongues in 1962 remained a Lutheran, went on receiving communion at the same rail, and argued with his synod rather than departing from it. This single decision made the second wave a renewal rather than a schism.

Key idea There is no membership roll for people who did not go anywhere.
1960

Bennett and why it detonated

On 3 April 1960, Dennis Bennett, rector of St. Mark's Episcopal Church in Van Nuys, told his congregation he had spoken in tongues. He resigned that day, and the national press carried the story. The lecture says it mattered because of the container. A denomination with bishops and a national office cannot leave such a question unanswered, and the ruling becomes policy.

Key idea An announcement in one parish became a question for every historic church.
Scripture

Why 1 Corinthians 12:7?

The lecture says both halves of its passages are load-bearing. This verse supplies the second half: the gifts are given for the profit of all, so every church that received the renewal had to ask what profit meant in practice and who decided.

But to each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the profit of all." 1 Corinthians 12:7 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why 1 Corinthians 12:11?

The lecture uses this verse for the first half of its point: the gifts are distributed as the Spirit chooses, which is why no institution can schedule them.

But the one and the same Spirit works all of these, distributing to each one separately as he desires." 1 Corinthians 12:11 · WEB
Order

Gifts inside a fixed liturgy

A eucharistic liturgy is fixed text led by an ordained person. A charismatic meeting expects that anyone may be given something to say. The historic churches mostly put the two in different rooms, with the renewal in midweek prayer groups and home groups. In theology they leaned on 1 Corinthians 12 to 14, where Paul restrains the public use of the gifts, and they reframed Spirit baptism as a given grace that is released.

Key idea Millions could say yes to the experience without calling their baptism empty.
Rome

The Catholic Charismatic Renewal

The Catholic Charismatic Renewal is conventionally dated to a student retreat at Duquesne University in February 1967. It came two years after the close of Vatican II, whose document Lumen Gentium had already said that the Spirit distributes special graces among the faithful of every rank. Cardinal Suenens was asked by Paul VI to accompany the renewal, and the Malines Documents kept it inside Catholic categories.

Key idea Vatican II had already written a paragraph into which the renewal fitted.
Cost

The shepherding controversy

In the 1970s several charismatic teachers developed a system in which every believer was submitted to a shepherd, in a chain of authority. The intention was to supply accountability to a movement running on individual experience. In practice, in many groups, it produced control of members' finances, employment, marriages and moves. The movement split over it, and in 1989 one of its leaders issued a public apology.

Key idea A renewal built on unmediated access to the Spirit found it needed authority.
Think about it

Two rooms in one church

The renewal often lived in the second slot of parish life while Sunday morning stayed as it was.

What is the risk when the little church inside the church becomes the real one and the parish becomes a shell?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The second wave brought the gifts into Episcopal, Lutheran, Catholic and other historic churches, and most adherents stayed where they were. It gave real ecumenical meetings but moved none of the church-dividing questions. It also had costs: the shepherding controversy, no reversal of mainline decline, and some charismatics who eventually left.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13