FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-2: The Second Vatican Council, 1962–1965

Vatican II was the Catholic Church deciding what it would say to the modern world. It moved towards its own sources, and it was questioned from two directions.

The Church in the Modern World

12 cards 29 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain aggiornamento and ressourcement as the council's two engines, and show why they were not the same impulse and sometimes pulled against each other.
  • State what Lumen Gentium taught about the People of God, episcopal collegiality and the universal call to holiness, and explain what turns on the phrase subsistit in.
  • Describe what Sacrosanctum Concilium and Dei Verbum actually changed in worship and in the doctrine of revelation — and separate the council's text from the reforms carried out afterwards in its name.
  • Assess the significance and the limits of Unitatis Redintegratio and Nostra Aetate, and account for the objections of those who judged the council excessive and those who judged it insufficient.
The council

Two engines

Vatican II had two mottos. Aggiornamento, John XXIII's word, means bringing up to date, and it protects the content of the faith while opening its language. Ressourcement means return to the sources: Scripture, the Fathers and the earliest liturgies. Most of the time the two reinforced each other, but after 1965 they came apart, with one party invoking the council's openness and another its sources.

Key idea One looks forward, the other looks back.
Lumen Gentium

The church describing itself

The Dogmatic Constitution on the Church was promulgated on 21 November 1964. The council rebuilt the preparatory draft so that chapter 2 treats the whole church as the People of God before chapter 3 treats the hierarchy. Chapter 3 still restates papal primacy and infallibility and adds collegiality, the bishops as a body with the pope as their head. Chapter 5 teaches the universal call to holiness.

Key idea Hierarchy exists inside the people, for the people.
At a glance

Two readings of subsistit in

The widely spread reading

Rome stopped identifying itself simply with the Church of Christ and conceded that other bodies are churches in some real sense.

The reading of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

Subsistit in affirms the full identity of the Church of Christ with the Catholic Church. Elements of sanctification and truth outside it are real, and are means of grace.

Scripture

Why Mark 2:22?

The lecture notes that this verse is often quoted from outside, assuming Rome was the old skin. It then says the bishops who pressed for change argued the wine was ancient and that the council was repairing the skins.

No one puts new wine into old wineskins, or else the new wine will burst the skins, and the wine pours out, and the skins will be destroyed; but they put new wine into fresh wineskins.”" Mark 2:22 · World English Bible
Liturgy and Bible

What changed, and what came later

Sacrosanctum Concilium, promulgated on 4 December 1963, takes full, conscious and active participation as its principle. It did not abolish Latin, and it did not command the priest to face the people. The Missal of Paul VI in 1969 came from a post-conciliar commission. Dei Verbum says Scripture and Tradition flow from one divine wellspring, and it authorises attention to literary forms.

Key idea Distinguish the council's text from the reforms done in its name.
Outward

Other Christians and other religions

Unitatis Redintegratio calls other Christians separated brethren, admits that people on both sides were to blame for divisions, and introduces the hierarchy of truths. Nostra Aetate, about 1,600 words long, says the passion of Christ cannot be charged against all Jews then living or today. It also says the church rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions, while proclaiming Christ as the way, the truth and the life. Dignitatis Humanae teaches a right to immunity from coercion in religious matters.

Key idea A new posture towards outsiders, with the central claims kept.
At a glance

Objections from both flanks

Judged excessive

Marcel Lefebvre held that Dignitatis Humanae contradicted earlier teaching and that a council contradicting earlier teaching is not binding at those points. He founded the Society of St Pius X in 1970.

Judged insufficient

Critics said the council raised expectations on contraception and the role of women and then did not decide. After Humanae Vitae in 1968, many concluded that collegiality had not been used at the first hard test.

Think about it

Reading change from outside

The lecture says a body can change its language, worship and posture without conceding its central claims, and outsiders will misread the change.

What changes in another tradition have you read as movement towards your own, and how would that tradition describe them?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Vatican II moved towards its own sources, not towards Protestants, and the overlap with Protestant instincts was real but incidental. Aggiornamento without ressourcement becomes accommodation, and ressourcement without aggiornamento becomes antiquarianism. Whether the council held both is an argument that has run for sixty years.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12