FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-1: Before Chalcedon: What Each Side Was Trying to Save

Four teachers, from the 370s to 451, each tried to protect something true about Christ. Each protected one half of the claim by risking the other.

The History of Christian Doctrine

15 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Apollinarius's actual argument (Christ has a human body and soul but the divine Word replaces a separate human mind or rational spirit), why he thought this protected Christ's unity, and Gregory of Nazianzus's rebuttal in the axiom "what is not assumed is not healed."
  • Describe the Theotokos controversy: what Nestorius was worried about, why "Mother of God" alarmed him, and why Cyril and the Council of Ephesus (431) judged that his alternative language endangered the unity of Christ's person.
  • Explain Cyril of Alexandria's hypostatic union — one person (hypostasis) in whom deity and humanity are united without confusion — as the technical solution both Nestorius and, later, Eutyches failed to hold.
  • Describe Eutyches's monophysite claim (one composite nature after the union, not two), why it alarmed both Rome and much of the East, and how the crisis it caused (including the "Robber Council" of Ephesus in 449) forced the Council of Chalcedon in 451.
The claim

Nobody wanted to say less

Apollinarius, Nestorius, Cyril and Eutyches all believed they were defending something the others put at risk. The lecture asks you to state each man's worry in a form he would call fair before you say what it cost him. The four controversies share one question: is Jesus Christ one person or two, and does he have one nature or two? Chalcedon would answer with a form of words rather than a philosophical system.

Key idea The sorting into orthodox and heretic happened, but the worry came first.
Scripture

Why John 1:14?

The lecture puts the weight of the whole chapter on John's word "flesh": nobody doubted the Word became flesh, but they argued over what "flesh" required.

The Word became flesh, and lived among us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the one and only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." John 1:14 · World English Bible
Apollinarius

Unity bought by shrinking humanity

Apollinarius feared that a full human being plus the divine Word would give a walking committee: two centres of thought and will in one body. So he kept Christ's human body and soul and let the Word himself fill the place of a human mind. That gave one subject. The price was a Christ with no human mind.

Key idea He was not indifferent to Christ's humanity; he wanted one someone.
The rebuttal

"What is not assumed is not healed"

Gregory of Nazianzus argued from salvation back to Christology. The human mind is the part that sins, doubts and needs reorienting toward God. If the Word never took it up, the incarnation never healed it. Christ redeems what he assumes and nothing more. Apollinarianism was condemned at Constantinople in 381.

Key idea The lecture treats this line as a method as well as a verdict.
Nestorius

Christ-bearer or God-bearer?

Nestorius, patriarch of Constantinople from 428, wanted to keep the divine and human sides of Christ distinct so that nothing unfitting was said of a changeless God. He objected to the title Theotokos, "God-bearer," and preferred Christotokos, "Christ-bearer." Cyril heard something worse: if Mary bore only a man, then Christ is two persons joined loosely, and it was never truly God who suffered for us. Nestorius denied teaching this.

Key idea Each man heard the other's language at its worst.
Ephesus 431

Theotokos is a claim about Christ

Ephesus condemned Nestorius and vindicated Theotokos, though the lecture notes that Cyril's allies opened proceedings before Nestorius's delegation arrived. The title is not mainly a claim about Mary's status. It says the child born of Mary is, without remainder, the same person as the eternal Son of God. The lecture calls it a Christological claim wearing Mariological clothing.

Key idea Rejecting the title was read as dividing Christ into two persons.
Cyril

The hypostatic union

Cyril's central claim is one hypostasis, one concrete subject, in whom two natures, divine and human, are united without confusion and without separation. The single subject is the eternal Word, who is born of Mary, hungers, suffers and dies as man. So Christians can say God was born in Bethlehem and also that God cannot be born. The first is true of the person, the second of the divine nature.

Key idea Later councils refined this vocabulary rather than replacing it.
Eutyches

One nature after the union

Eutyches took Cyril's anti-Nestorian instinct without the checks Cyril built in. He taught that Christ was of two natures before the incarnation but of one nature after it, the human nature absorbed by the divine. This is the origin of the label monophysite. Many churches later grouped under it prefer miaphysite, one united nature that is both fully divine and fully human.

Key idea The lecture flags that the label matters again in the next lecture.
Scripture

Why Philippians 2:6-7?

The lecture rests the other half of the argument on Paul's "form of a servant," asking how far it can be pressed before "the form of God" is lost.

who, existing in the form of God, didn't consider equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men." Philippians 2:6-7 · WEB
At a glance

What each side protected, and its cost

Apollinarius

Protected one subject by letting the Word replace the human mind. Cost: an unhealed human mind. Condemned at Constantinople, 381.

Nestorius

Protected God's changelessness by preferring Christ-bearer. Cost as read by opponents: two persons loosely joined. Condemned at Ephesus, 431.

Eutyches

Pushed Cyril's language further to one blended nature. Cost: humanity absorbed, no longer fully what needed redeeming. Robber Council 449, then Chalcedon 451.

Think about it

Intention or words?

Nestorius denied that he taught two persons, yet the council judged that his language amounted to that regardless of his intent.

Does a theologian's stated intention matter, or only what the words actually commit him to? Defend your answer.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The one who saves must be fully God and fully human, one person. Apollinarius, Nestorius and Eutyches each protected one half of that claim by risking the other, and Cyril's hypostatic union tried to hold both. The Robber Council of 449 forced Chalcedon in 451. When you correct a doctrinal error, name what its holder was trying to protect before you name what it costs.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 15