FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-3: Medieval to Reformation Christology

Two of the most consequential Christological moves hide inside arguments usually filed under other headings: Anselm's account of why God became man, and the Lutheran and Reformed split over Christ's human nature.

The History of Christian Doctrine

12 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why Anselm's satisfaction theory in Cur Deus Homo is a Christological argument before it is an atonement theory: why the one who satisfies must, in Anselm's logic, be both fully God and fully man, and could be no one else.
  • Describe the basic shape of Aquinas's Christology in the Summa Theologiae — his treatment of the hypostatic union, Christ's human knowledge, and Christ's human will — as a systematic ordering of Chalcedonian categories rather than a new departure from them.
  • Define the communicatio idiomatum ("communication of properties") as the classical Christological principle that properties of either of Christ's natures may be predicated of the one person, and explain why this principle, agreed by all sides, still produced a Reformation-era Lutheran/Reformed split.
  • State the specific disagreement over Christ's bodily presence and ubiquity that divided Lutheran and Reformed Christology, and how it fed directly into the Lord's Supper controversy this course covers again in chapter 5.
Anselm

A Christology disguised as an atonement theory

Anselm of Canterbury wrote Cur Deus Homo around 1098 in answer to a question unbelievers were asking: why must God become man, and could he not simply forgive? Sin against an infinite God incurs an infinite debt, and no creature has a surplus to pay it, so the payer must be God. The debt is a human one, and it is fitting that the same nature that incurred it should pay it, so the payer must also be man. The God-Man is therefore a logical requirement of the doctrine, not a contingent detail.

Key idea The lecture reads it as a descendant of the Chalcedonian claim.
Where traditions differ

Satisfaction in different keys

Anselm's satisfaction language came from the penitential and feudal-honor vocabulary of his century. Reformation theologians sharpened it into a more penal and forensic register, bearing a penalty in the sinner's place. Eastern Orthodox theology has generally been cooler toward the whole framework, preferring Christus Victor and theosis. The narrower point is less contested: nearly every tradition affirms that no one less than the God-Man could do what needed doing.

Key idea The lecture says this is a point where readers will not agree.
Aquinas

Architecture, not innovation

Thomas Aquinas, writing his Summa Theologiae in the 1260s and 1270s, did not reopen what Chalcedon and Constantinople III had closed. He built the settled categories, one person, two natures, two wills, into a complete structure and answered many subordinate questions. One example is Christ's human knowledge, both direct knowledge of God and ordinary acquired knowledge. Another is how his human will stays free even though it cannot sin. Later Catholic and Protestant theology accepted, modified or reacted against this framework.

Key idea Aquinas gave Chalcedonian Christology its fullest Western scholastic treatment.
One principle

The communication of properties

The communicatio idiomatum says that because Christ is one person in two natures, properties of either nature may be truthfully said of the person. So "God suffered" is true, though suffering belongs to the human nature, and a man is worshipped as Lord of glory, though that title belongs to the divine. Neither statement means the divine nature itself became capable of suffering. Every Chalcedonian theologian accepts this principle, and it is simply Cyril's Christology worked out in careful sentences.

Key idea Agreement on the principle still did not prevent a Reformation split.
Scripture

Why Matthew 26:26-27?

Luther, Zwingli and Calvin could not avoid how to read "this is my body," and each answer depended on what body the ascended Christ now has.

As they were eating, Jesus took bread, gave thanks for it, and broke it. He gave to the disciples, and said, 'Take, eat; this is my body.' He took the cup, gave thanks, and gave to them, saying, 'All of you drink it,'" Matthew 26:26-27 · World English Bible
At a glance

Lutheran and Reformed Christology

Luther: genus majestaticum

Through the personal union Christ's human nature really possesses divine attributes, including a form of omnipresence. His glorified body can be truly present in, with and under the bread and wine wherever the Supper is celebrated.

Calvin and the Reformed: extra Calvinisticum

A human body is located in one place, now at the Father's right hand. The eternal Word also acts beyond the assumed humanity, and believers feed on Christ's body by the Spirit in a spiritual real presence.

The Supper

A Christological dispute underneath

The Reformation argument over "this is my body" turned first on what the personal union does to the properties of Christ's human nature. The lecture insists this is not about who takes Christ's presence more seriously. Every position covered, Lutheran, Reformed, Zwinglian and Catholic, intends to honor Christ's own words and reality. Chapter 5 returns to the dispute from the sacramental side.

Key idea Each tradition should recognise its own position as stated fairly.
Think about it

Which concern would you have prioritized?

A Lutheran finds the genus majestaticum necessary to honor Christ's words at the Supper. A Reformed believer finds the extra Calvinisticum necessary to honor what a real human body is.

If you had been present at Marburg in 1529, which concern would you have prioritized, and why?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Anselm's argument shows that only the God-Man could do what was needed, and Aquinas arranged the settled categories into a full system. All sides accept the communication of properties, but Luther and Calvin differed on whether the human nature itself holds divine attributes. That difference shaped the Lord's Supper dispute. When Christians disagree about the Supper, first ask what each side believes about Christ's human nature.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12