FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-3: Puritan Hope and the Rise of Postmillennialism

Postmillennialism expected a golden age of gospel success within history, before Christ returns. It arose tied to a particular moment of revival and confidence.

The History of Christian Doctrine

12 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Define postmillennialism and distinguish it from both the earlier chiliasm of 7-1 and Augustine's present-church-age amillennialism of 7-2.
  • Explain Daniel Whitby's argument for a coming golden age of the gospel and identify what made his proposal new rather than a simple return to earlier chiliasm.
  • Describe how Jonathan Edwards read the revivals of his own day — the Great Awakening — as evidence that the millennium's advance had, in some sense, already begun.
  • Name what changed in the twentieth century to make sustained postmillennial confidence far less common than it had been, without concluding that the position itself was thereby disproven.
Definition

A third position

After roughly twelve centuries of Augustine's settlement, a third position emerged in the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. It agreed with Augustine that the millennium is not primarily inaugurated by Christ's visible return. But it held that the millennium is a future, better phase of the church age, a golden era of gospel success that the church's own preaching and revival help bring about. Later theology called this postmillennialism: Christ returns after the millennium.

Key idea The lecture studies it at its most historically specific moment.
Daniel Whitby

A new argument, not old chiliasm revived

Whitby, an English clergyman around the turn of the eighteenth century, gave postmillennialism its first sustained statement. He expected large Jewish conversions, the gospel reaching Islamic and pagan nations, and a lengthy period of peace and purity achieved through ordinary preaching. Only after this worldwide flourishing would Christ return. The chiliasts of 7-1 expected Christ's return to begin the reign; Whitby expected it to be a capstone.

Key idea Whitby held unusual views on other doctrines, and the lecture says that does not decide the question.
Jonathan Edwards

Revival as evidence

Edwards lived through and helped lead the revivals of the 1730s and 1740s, later called the Great Awakening. In works such as Some Thoughts Concerning the Present Revival of Religion in New England, he argued that these revivals were plausible evidence that the advance toward the millennium had already begun. In An Humble Attempt he called for concerted, transatlantic prayer. For him the revival was itself a piece of the theological evidence.

Key idea His postmillennialism is inseparable from his experience of the 1740s.
At a glance

Three positions on when Christ returns

Chiliasm (7-1)

Christ's visible return comes first and inaugurates a thousand-year earthly reign.

Augustine (7-2)

The thousand years is the present church age, from Christ's first coming to his second.

Postmillennialism (7-3)

A future golden age of gospel success comes through ordinary means, and Christ returns afterwards.

Its moment

An eschatology of confidence

Puritan and early American postmillennialism flourished when much historical evidence seemed to its proponents to point the same way. There were transatlantic revivals, an expanding Protestant missionary movement and, for many in the nineteenth century, reforms such as the abolition of slavery, prison reform and temperance. Through most of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries it was the dominant eschatology of English-speaking missions and reform movements, not a minority position.

Key idea Another case where an assumption about the dominant view ran ahead of the record.
What changed

The twentieth century

Two world wars, the Holocaust and a general experience of catastrophic, technologically enabled violence made the nineteenth-century assumption of progress much harder to sustain. Postmillennialism did not disappear, and a more modest form persists today as a live evangelical option. But the confidence of an Edwards became much rarer after 1918 and rarer still after 1945.

Key idea A position's mood changing is not the same as the position being refuted.
Scripture

Why Habakkuk 2:14?

The lecture says postmillennial writers read this verse, with other passages, as describing a coming period of gospel success within history before Christ returns.

For the earth will be filled with the knowledge of Yahweh's glory, as the waters cover the sea." Habakkuk 2:14 · World English Bible
Think about it

Evidence or foundation?

Edwards treated the revivals he witnessed as evidence for a claim about the millennium's advance.

What is the difference between using present events as confirming evidence for a prior biblical hope and building the hope out of present events in the first place, and which did Edwards actually do?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Postmillennialism expects a golden age within history, brought by ordinary gospel means, before Christ returns, and Edwards saw revival as a sign it had begun. Its loss of confidence after 1918 and 1945 does not prove it false. Hold your hopes about history with humility, and test them against Scripture rather than the mood of your own moment.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12