FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-2: Neo-Orthodoxy's Answer

Barth answered liberal theology with a God who is wholly other and known only by his own self-revelation. The movement he launched fits neither the conservative nor the liberal label.

The History of Christian Doctrine

13 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what event and what theological judgment prompted Karl Barth to write The Epistle to the Romans (Römerbrief), and what he meant by describing God as "wholly other."
  • State the Barth-Brunner dispute over natural theology accurately from both sides: Emil Brunner's argument in Nature and Grace and Karl Barth's response, Nein! ("No!").
  • Identify at least two respects in which neo-orthodoxy returned to classical theological categories, and at least two respects in which it innovated beyond both classical orthodoxy and the liberal theology it was reacting against.
  • Explain why flattening neo-orthodoxy into either "conservative" or "liberal" misdescribes the movement, using specific evidence from this lecture.
The catastrophe

August 1914

Karl Barth trained under leading liberal Protestant theologians. In August 1914 a list of ninety-three German intellectuals published a manifesto defending the Kaiser's war policy, and Barth discovered that nearly all his former professors had signed it. He concluded that a theology built on finding God within the historical and cultural process has no resources to say "no" when that process goes catastrophically wrong.

Key idea The lecture says this broke his confidence in a single, specific way.
Romans

A God who is wholly other

As a parish pastor in Safenwil, Barth wrote a commentary on Romans, published in 1919 and rewritten in 1922. His central term for the God he found there was "wholly other". God does not stand at the top of a scale that includes humanity's highest achievements, but confronts humanity from an entirely different order of being. God is reachable only by his own free act of self-revelation, never by reason, religious feeling or cultural progress.

Key idea A reviewer called the book a bomb dropped on the playground of the theologians.
Brunner

A formal point of contact

Emil Brunner shared much of Barth's critique of liberal theology. In Nature and Grace (1934) he argued that Barth's total rejection of natural theology went further than Scripture or necessity required. He distinguished the material content of natural knowledge, which fallen humanity cannot reach, from a formal capacity that survives the fall: the capacity to be addressed and to respond. Without it, he said, the gospel would have nothing to land on.

Key idea Brunner did not claim natural theology could save anyone.
Barth's reply

Nein!

Barth's answer in the same year was titled Nein! (No!). His objection was that any point of contact conceded to exist in fallen human nature, however minimal, reintroduces a foothold from the human side that revelation merely completes. He held that grace supplies its own points of contact as it addresses a person. In 1934 the so-called German Christian movement was arguing that German blood, soil and national identity were a further source of revelation, so he saw the stakes as real.

Key idea The lecture calls this a live disagreement within one family, and does not resolve it.
At a glance

Two views on natural theology

Brunner

A formal capacity for address survives the fall, resting partly on the image of God. The gospel engages it rather than creating it from nothing.

Barth

Any independent foothold in fallen nature lets revelation merely activate something human. Grace creates its own point of contact in the act of address.

At a glance

Neither conservative nor liberal

Toward the classical

The Trinity belongs at the opening of theology, revelation in Christ is objectively real, and historical reconstruction of the real Jesus cannot ground faith.

Toward innovation

Revealer, Revelation and Revealedness replace the classical Trinitarian language. Scripture is the witness to revelation, not identical with it. Natural theology is rejected totally.

Why no label fits

Both camps have tried to claim Barth

Neo-orthodoxy used classical-sounding commitments to attack liberal theology's method. It also rejected enough of both classical and liberal content that neither side of the later conservative and liberal divide could claim Barth as its own. Aquinas, Calvin and most Reformation confessions affirmed some real if limited natural knowledge of God, so his total "Nein!" is itself an innovation. Evangelical theologians still criticise his view of Scripture on exactly this point.

Key idea Neither claim survives contact with the specifics.
Scripture

Why Isaiah 55:8-9?

The lecture calls it a direct statement of divine transcendence, close to the verse Barth's project could be read as a meditation on. It does not settle how much of God can be known from the human side.

For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways," says Yahweh. "For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts." Isaiah 55:8-9 · World English Bible
Think about it

How narrow is too narrow?

Brunner's point of contact is explicitly formal, a capacity for address and not a saving knowledge of God.

Does Barth's total rejection actually engage that distinction, or does it treat any concession as equally dangerous regardless of how narrow it is?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Barth held that God is known only through God's own act of self-revelation, never from the human side, and he built this view as a reaction to 1914. Do not file neo-orthodoxy as a simple return to conservative orthodoxy, because Barth also departed from classical teaching. State a view you disagree with in its strongest form first, as Brunner's modest point of contact deserved.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13