FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-3: Twentieth-Century Diversification

In the twentieth century the question of who does theology, and from where, became part of the debate. The lecture describes three positions on their own terms before evaluating any of them.

The History of Christian Doctrine

13 cards 21 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Gustavo Gutiérrez's central claim in liberation theology — that salvation has an inescapable social and political dimension — in the strongest form its own proponents would recognize, and name the specific criticism the Vatican raised against it.
  • Locate at least three distinct positions across the range of twentieth-century feminist theology, from reformist to post-Christian, and explain honestly how far apart those positions actually stand from each other theologically.
  • Explain what Kwame Bediako and Kosuke Koyama each argued about doing theology outside a European conceptual frame, using a specific concept from each theologian's own work.
  • Explain why this lecture insists on describing each of these positions on its own terms before evaluating any of them, and what is lost if that order is reversed.
A shift

The location becomes a question

Every theologian named earlier in the course wrote from the Mediterranean, then European, then North Atlantic world. That was simply where Christianity's institutional and academic centres of gravity sat for most of its first nineteen centuries. The twentieth century is the first period in which that location itself became a question: who has been doing the asking, and what does the tradition look like from somewhere else?

Key idea Teach each position on its own terms before evaluating it.
Gutiérrez

Salvation has a social dimension

Gustavo Gutiérrez, a Peruvian priest, published A Theology of Liberation out of pastoral work in the barrios of Lima. He argued that salvation cannot be reduced to a private transaction between a soul and God, because the Exodus, the prophets and Luke 4 refuse that reduction. His phrase "preferential option for the poor" says that God is not neutral between rich and poor in situations of structural injustice. His most careful proponents rejected the charge that the gospel is reducible to politics.

Key idea Base ecclesial communities read Scripture together in light of their own circumstances.
The Vatican's verdict

Two instructions, a two-part verdict

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued two instructions on liberation theology. The 1984 instruction criticised specific uses of Marxist analysis it judged uncritical, and warned against reducing salvation to a purely this-worldly liberation. The 1986 instruction affirmed the preferential option for the poor as authentically Christian and consistent with the church's social teaching. The lecture summarises it this way: the central claim persuaded even its authoritative critics, while some methods did not.

Key idea Read both instructions together; the second is easy to miss.
At a glance

A spectrum within feminist theology

Reformist: Aída Besançon Spencer

Argues for women's ministry from within an evangelical, high view of biblical authority, disagreeing with other evangelicals only on specific texts.

Revisionist: Rosemary Radford Ruether

Holds that the tradition's content contains patriarchal distortion needing substantial reconstruction, within a recognisably Christian framework.

Post-Christian: Mary Daly

Holds that patriarchy is constitutive of the tradition, so liberation means moving beyond Christianity, not reforming it.

The distance

Not one continuous argument

Spencer and Daly are not two points on one argument that differ only in degree. Spencer affirms biblical inerrancy, the Trinity and Christ's unique saving work as the earlier chapters describe them. Daly rejected the whole framework as the problem to be escaped. Calling both simply feminist theology, without naming that distance, flattens a real theological disagreement into a false unity.

Key idea The shared starting point is that the tradition was written overwhelmingly by men.
Bediako

Christ as ancestor

Kwame Bediako, a Ghanaian theologian trained in patristics, argued that African converts were not adopting a wholly foreign religion onto a blank slate. African primal religions had already prepared them to take ancestors, spirit and an interpenetrating spiritual world seriously. He drew a parallel with the second-century apologists, who explained the faith in the vocabulary of their own culture. His own particular interest was a Christology of Christ as ancestor.

Key idea He argued that Western rationalism had often lost these categories.
Koyama

Theology at three miles an hour

Kosuke Koyama, a Japanese theologian who taught in Thailand, argued in Waterbuffalo Theology for theology at the pace of an ox in a Thai rice paddy: patient, humble and locally rooted. He judged Western missionary theology had often been delivered at an impatient and abstract pace. In Mount Sinai and Mount Fuji he contrasted the biblical God's ethical, historical self-revelation with a Japanese sensibility oriented towards the aesthetic and the cyclical.

Key idea Neither he nor Bediako diluted doctrine to make it palatable.
Scripture

Why Luke 4:18-19?

The lecture says it names concrete conditions and a spiritual mission together, so every theologian in the lecture takes a position on how literally to read it.

The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to heal the brokenhearted, to proclaim release to the captives, recovering of sight to the blind, to deliver those who are crushed, and to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord." Luke 4:18-19 · World English Bible
Think about it

What does Luke 4 settle?

Luke 4:18-19 names concrete conditions, poverty, captivity and blindness, in the same breath as a spiritual mission.

Does the text itself settle how literally those conditions should be taken, or does it leave real interpretive room that different readers in different circumstances have filled differently?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Gutiérrez's central claim, that salvation has a real social and political dimension, persuaded even its official critics at Rome, although some of the methods used did not. Feminist theology is not one position, since Spencer, Ruether and Daly stand at real distance from each other. Listen to a view from another place or experience, and describe it so its holders would agree, before you evaluate it.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13